Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avi: is good I like how simple it looks :ryan:

Sig 1: Very cute. The font is absolutely gorgeous. And I like the winter affect the siggy has. 9/10 :ryan:

Sig 2: GORGE-OUS! :cali: Not one thing that I don't like about it.
11/10

Just a very purrty signature set you got here. :ryan:
 
Wow you have a really pretty set! The avatar gets a nice 9/10 I really love how simple it is and how it gives off a light clean feel about it. I wish it a were a bit bigger :3 The signature gets a super 10/10. It's absolutely stunning! I just love everything about it! Every small detail just catches my eyes and wont let them go until they bleed beauty o__O.
 
the set just amazing, the render just looks sooo awesome the blending you done a great job with blending the render/stock in, may need a bit more lighting to add depth but apart from that it a great peice good job :)

9/10 for set
 

Since the sig and avvy are pretty much the same, I'll rate them the same.

10/10. The coloring is perfect, the stock is so clear, its the perfect size, and I love the subtle shimmery effects. Some effects are a bit too in your face for me, but I'm really liking the shimmer effect Loui is using in a lot of her sigs now. Its very tastefully done.
 
I'm just going to rate this as a set: 9/10

I like the lighting and the effects around the wings, everything fits in nicely, and the text suits too.
 
OMG that signature looks soooo good :D the blending of the stock/render is perfectly done :D also the lighting in the signature is just beautiful, the text rounds off the signature very nicely :D

9/10 for this one
 
Set: It's nice and I like the smokey effect. Could be bigger but I know there was a formatting issue with it.

8/10 :ryan:
 
Set: 10/10

I love black and white sigs and I love the cute, soft purple flare over him and the text. It makes a simplistic signature really stand out and catch your eye. Very pretty. :ryan:
 
signature: 10/10 very nice, clean, colourful and the blending amazing, loving the text as well

Avatar: 8/10 a bit simple but i'm loving the subject and the animation, very cute :inlove:
 
Sig: 9/10 I LOVE the colours, the way you've framed the image and the simple lighting effects. Have you added a render over a different background? If so, it works very well as a complete image as I didn't notice at first! :lew: I'm not 100% sure about the text. I like the font you've used for 'Molly x Nephrite,' but the white text is a little too distant from this, making the text itself look a bit more chunky and harsh against the rest of this gorgeous, soft piece. :)

Avatar is simple and well framed again. 8/10
 
Those are incredibly precise scores, considering you only wrote one sentence for each piece. So presumably with the decimal points, you are rating sets on a scale with 100 different scores. How do you decide the difference between a 6.7 and a 6.8? What are the key differences and what criterion do you score on?

Avatar 7.645626562578365626362/10
Top signature 4.882768193873/10
Bottom signature 8.10103984/10
 
^I just go based on my personal opinions. doesn't matter how long the sentence is. And why do you care about my opinions, anyways? Seriously, if you are gonna go on about my own opinions and not give me opinions on my sig, then why bother. xD

And I guess this one is okay. A little simple tbh. It's got vibrancy going for it, but sadly I think that's it. 6.5/10
 
lmfao you're very harsh on sigs Ken :wacky:

Anyway
Avatar: 8/10, I love that it is circular and i love the colours and stuff, I guess I'm just not so fond of the actual picture used.
Sig 1: 6/10, Lighting is good and I like the colours but i think a little more could be done to it, the text is a teensie bit plain for me and I guess the background needs something to it.
Sig 2: 9/10, I love everything about it except the picture used but that's not the artists fault. The text is especially good I think.
 
Last edited:
WOAH buddy calm down. Don't need to rate my sig poorly just because you just got told. I have just about had it with people acting like they're fucking experts when their sigs are hardly anything to boast about

You are saying that the ND one is simple but a render on a blue background is not? As if simple was a bad thing anyway

Sadly I think the Thane sig is fine but the only thing it has going for it is the blue and lighting, I think that is why I think it's ok, u kno, no real flow in it since the dissolve effects are something a 3 year old could do 0.11234232/10
 
...okay........ :wacky:

Icon: It's gorgeous. I love the round shape and the lighting is obvious good. :ryan: To me, it just looks very magical, makes me feel like I'm reading a fantasy book. :lew: Don't ask why, IDK :ahmed:

sig: brilliant lighting(obviously) I love the mirrored image in the text(used to love doing that :lew: ) and I think it looks very pretty, gentle and just very nice to look at. It draws me into the focal point. I also love the white smudgy effect near her face.

Brilliant set, very relaxing and gentle on the eyes, a nice/rare talent in gfx if you ask me.

Perfect score is what I give it. ♥

oh, and the balls comment, ditch it :hmph: I give that a -0 :hal:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top