Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avvy: 8/10 I like it, but other than the border, there doesn't seem to be much going on.

Sig: 9.5/10 Much like the avvy, there isn't much going on. However, the text was done well, and I rather like the image used.
 
Funny thing, I didn't use any textures :lew:. I used a displacement map, and the other effects were done by filters :ryan:.

Avvy - Pretty sick, and lighting is good. 8/10

Sig is coolio, but it just feels lacking of something - but still good. 8.6/10

EDIT: :rage: Ninja'd! :rage:

Sig is cool, but seems empty D: 7.1/10

Avatar is nice. 8/10
 
Aqua set: 8/10 overall

avi: I like the aqua Avi alot and the lighting effects rock! I can't help but want it to be an exact crop of the siggy but having it a little more colorful never hurt :P

Sig: I love it! The 0only thing I'd say is to work on the text. Also a bit of the space to the right could be cropped out. I see what you were going for but its a tad too much emptiness in my personal opinion. Good job ^_^

Sig2: 7/10 I love the background and how the text seems to flow into it. One thing I would say that bothers me is the image of Squall. His arm kinda looks a bit awkward and outlined as well as his gunblade in some areas. I also think Squall could have been blended in more ^_^ That's it for now though. It's a very decent, well made piece!
 
Av: 8/10 Pretty mysterious and mystifying colours. Too plain maybe?

Sig: 8/10 Textures suit the colours. Decorative text is niiice. Too bright maybe?
 
Avatar: 9/10, Its got pretty colouring, the picture is nice and its just simple in a good way :D

Sig: 7/10: Its pretty but its not really eye catching, it probably needs some more lighting effects or something, still nice though :)
 
Avatar 9/10 - it has a lot of emotion. The plain, clean look of the image just works well.

Sig 8.5/10 - On the one hand, the quality is great and it's a work of art. If we're just going to judge it from an art perspective, I have no problems with it. But then again, somehow I think the lines actually get in a way a little bit here and the monotony is something I'm not a big fan of for this image.
 
Avvy - 7/10, the colors are nice and I like the simplicity, but I'm not sure I like how it's cropped :hmmm: Maybe if you could in both faces...?

Sig - 9.5/10, :XD: a veeeeery close 10. The colors are superb and the text is great. It's just so pretty, but I think the lighting could use a little work. It's still very pretty ^_^
 
Avatar - 6/10, It's looks as if it was mushed in. Other than that though, I love the color. That is all.

Sig - 7/10, Like in the Avatar, I like the color. I also like the fact that the fire itself is the focal point, or the emphasis. It could use a bit brightening and maybe a light color gradient.
 
Last edited:
Avi: 7/10

I like the colour scheme and the font around it.

Sig: 8/10

I like the splatter texture around the focal, and the lighting is good, although the font is nice, the placement of it doesn't look right, it's not majorly a problem though, it's an awesome tag ^^
 
Sig - 9/10 I Love lightning....but not only because of that I like how you've presented the different shades of yellow,and the font of the writing. If you had another color like red or something I probably woulda gave it a 10.

Avatar - 9/10 I like how you've cropped it in....it wouldve been better if it was slightly bigger.
 
6/10 for the avvy...really Shadow you need a cool new avvvy of Shadow that sticks out a little more in my opinion....


9/10 for the Terra siggy. I think Livvi had the same pic of Terra in her last sig and I loved it. I love this one too...Ari does such a good job on her work. I love how crisp the picture looks and how the lighting focuses on Terra's face. The text blends in a little easily but its still a very nice looking sig overall.
 
Avvy - 8/10, pretty colors! It's a nice crop and I just love the colors and simplicity. ^_^

Sig - 9/10, I like it a lot, but the text is not that noticeable and a little hard to read. Also you can't go wrong with borders....... but anyway it's still really lovely. :D
 
Yuffie amirite :hmmm:


7/10 for the avvy...it looks like a crop from the original sig, but its cute. I do like the coloring because it makes it pop just a bit.

8/10 for the siggy... I like the effect of the hand on the picture because it makes it look like a bit of a reflection. The text is a little small...and there's quite a bit of it...but the pic of Yuffie herself looks pretty decent :monster:
 
Avi: 7/10

I like the colours around the focal, a border would have made it look complete though.

Sig: 7.5/10

Again, I like the colours, and the placement of the focal is good, however, a few things that get my attention include the text and the corners in particular, the font is really pretty, but it doesn't stand out enough for us to read it, the little bits on the corners, however, are too bold and could do with a bit of blending in, it is really pretty overall though :)
 
Oh! Kat I think this set is my favorite from you yet ^o^

Aerith avi gets a 9/10 because it's so beautiful! I lOVE the colors. If there was more of a close up on her face o if she were a tad bit bigger it would be near perfect ^^. An excellent crop of the sig.

Sig gets a 9/10. Despite the picture quality I think this sig works really well. The color is amazing and works really well for Aerith. I love the text although I fell like the Flower Girl part could have been a tab bolder. I love the background off to the sides and the lighting. The border gives it a really nice finish ^_^
 
Lil'Redskx said:
Oh! Kat I think this set is my favorite from you yet ^o^

Aerith avi gets a 9/10 because it's so beautiful! I lOVE the colors. If there was more of a close up on her face o if she were a tad bit bigger it would be near perfect ^^. An excellent crop of the sig.

Sig gets a 9/10. Despite the picture quality I think this sig works really well. The color is amazing and works really well for Aerith. I love the text although I fell like the Flower Girl part could have been a tab bolder. I love the background off to the sides and the lighting. The border gives it a really nice finish ^_^
Click to expand...

Aww wow, thank you ^^

Avi: 8/10

I like the set altogether, the stock is pretty nice and other than a small border on it, which would make it look more complete, nothing else would need to be added for it really.

Sig: 8/10
Again I like the stock and the colours in it, and I like the way the lighting is placed as well, my only critisism is the text, I think a simple font and a better placement is needed, as it doesn't really blend in with the rest of the tag. I'm liking the border as well though, good job!
 
Set: 7/10

It looks nice and matches well but I think the text in the Signature could use a little work, its a bit plain and the pattern behind the character is a little odd, but it still looks great! The avatar is fine how it is :D
 
Avatar : 5/10 . It's really just a plain shot of Riku. Nothing much is really going in it. But I like Riku, so I'll give ya that. :ryan:

Signature : 8.5/10 . Though I'm not very big on the SoraxRiku stuff, I will say that is a cute fanart of choice. The signature was well edited, but simple as well - and I enjoy simplicity more than anything. :ryan: Though, I think there could be 1 or 2 less little hearts in it. :lew: The ones on the right side look a little bit out of place. But a cute signature, regardless .
​
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top