Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
avi: 8.5/10 very thoguht provoking and nice colours
sig: 9/10 nice texture
 
av - 7/10 nice colours, good size and i like the addition of the tiny text, very nicely done.

sig 8/10 - great lighting and use of gradients, i like the textured background and border. Not sure about the font type but the placement is great.
 
Avatar 6/10: It's not a bad avatar. I like how it's cropped and the colour is nice, it's just that there wasn't a lot done to it, but it's still nice.

Signature 10/10: I love it. It's looks so clean and simple but there's obviously a lot of work done in it. I love the lighting is really nice at the top, the colours are very mellow and with some warmth in it, and the little brushes are a nice touch. The over-all smudging and blurring is just great too ^^
 
@ Safer Sephiroth;

6/10 Avatar, simple, but nice.

8/10 Siggy, Love the Jenova Specimen text, and the little glimmer-ish siggy. Just a really nice piece. ^^
 
Avvy: CUTE! 9/10
Siggy1: awesome 10/10
Siggy2: also awesome 8/10
 
Avatar: 6/10

It's a decent enough avatar. It's a bit too harsh/sharp/sketchy for my liking. It needs a soft layer and I think the original image was of low quality. The border is a nice touch, as is the text. It's just the quality of the image that needs a look at.

Sig: 7/10


I like the idea of the background. Very creative. I just don't like how faded it all looks. Aerith needs more light! XD The text is nice and the colours work well. Just needs a look at lighting and the size should be a tad smaller in my opinion. Too much empty space.

Note: I did not make my current avatar! But I forgot where I actually got it from originally so I have no one to credit. =0
 
Last edited:
avatar: 9/ 10 love the way how you have writing in between heads. very nice.

sig: 9/ 10 like the texture and the colours.
 
9/10 Avatar: I love how it looks, it's sort of haunting to me a bit. Very nice =P
7/10 Signature: It's kinda small a bit hard to really see too well.

=]
 
Avatar - 8/10. I really like it! I like the colors in the avatar and I like the effects in it too ^^ It's really nice

Signature - 5/10. I thought the text was the focus of the piece, and I think that the character should be the focus, not the text. It's a touch too small, and needs more blending too ^^ It shows promise though.
 
Avatar: always nice to have a matching av and sig. I'm a big Stevie Nicks fan myself, so I have appreciation for the image. She is beautiful in photos - I don't think I've ever seen a bad one of her. I think the avy could do with a border of some kind, though. 7/10

Sig: Love the Fleetwood Mac/Stevie lyrical quotes, especially the one from Silver Springs - such a powerful lyric. First banner of Aeris is really nice, the colours are very subtle and it works well. The second of Stevie is just gorgeous. ^_^ beautiful photo choice, and the background looks like it was always meant to be there. :) It could maybe do with some subtle text..or something in that spare space. 9/10.

Both my sig and av were made by me. Everything in the background of the banner was drawn by me, including the fire.
 
Av; uhh. 7/10, mebbe? i like the sense of mystery it gives, and the transparency. bit plain, though. matches the sig, which is nice.

Sig; the strange light overlay within the black one irritates me a little, i suppose it's meant to add brightness or something. but I don't like it. also plain, but the fire is very well done. 8/10.

mebbe just rate my avatar :gasp: are quotes even rateable?
 
8/10 for your avvi - i like the colours and simplicity ^_^

i dont know if quotes can be rated :/ if they could i'd probs give it a 7/10. they're pretty funny lol
 
7/10 Avi= OK, perhaps a little colour?

9/10 Sig= Wow. Loving the colours and the texture.
 
Avatar - 9/10
I love that image of Rinoa and the blue goes so well with her to make a nicely toned piece.

Signature - 5/10
It's cute. Though very big, perhaps try a smaller size so there is less space to fill? The text is a little plain. Though I'm loving the little stars around the border. They're so cute!
 
Avatar: I honestly have no complaints about it. Well done! I especially like the triple x. 10/10

1st tag: Just a liiiiitle more blending on her left arm to the background. But that's about it. I think it's fantastic. The size, type and placement of the text is spot-on. Nice colors and it's crisp. :gasp: 9.8/10

2nd tag: Fantastic. This is very good. I like the angle, the size and the colors used. My only comment is that the left side seems a little empty, regardless of the text. But still...great work Vikkivikki <3. 9/10
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top