SOTW 47 Voting

Which signature is best?

  • Total voters
    26
  • Poll closed .
L

L

Iller than Radiation
Veteran
Joined
Jan 15, 2007
Messages
4,105
Age
35
Gil
21
FFXIV
Ellen Stone
FFXIV Server
Adamantoise
1.
Balthier.png


2.
2copyzz3.png


3.
entry.jpg


4.
MM.png


5.
1z2jfok.png
 
My vote goes for #1. I tend to find the busier graphics to be the most attractive. It looks like it was time-consuming to create.
 
Definitely #4. The subject matter owns the others. M&M man thing = ownage. The effects are pretty cool, too.
 
I was torn between 2 and 3. In the end, 3 won out. I really like the colouring and lighting on it. The angle of the stock is quite nice too.

Great work on number 2, nice and simple. Bit of a dodgy size though. =/
 
I'm between 1 and 3.

I like the simple style used in 3. The flow is also very good. 1 has nice text and looks as though there was a lot of effort put into the background and the effects.

Maybe I'll make a decision later.

I can tell who did every piece with the exception of 4. :wacky:
 
Last edited:
I'm going for #1 because I love the light background behind Balthier which contrasts to the dark background elsewhere, and as Claymore has pointed out it looks as if a lot of effort has been put into the background.
Kudos to #1 :wink:
 
It was between 1, 3, and 5 for me.

1 was really good, in a way that it really shows great effects in the background. The text is also well-placed and I quite like it. The only thing that doesn't really appeal to me is the darker background on the left and right side and would have much preferred it if the artist just stuck with the color theme in the center as I really loved that part since it blended really well with the render. Other than that, this one was a really decent entry.

3 is also beautiful in a very simplistic way. I like the subtle effect and how there's really not too much going on in the background. The way Yuffie was placed is also quite interesting and I like it a lot. But somehow, I feel that the signature isn't complete for some reason. =/ Like maybe one more very subtle effect in the background would've sufficed as it seems too empty for me somewhat.

5 was kinda different from the rest and I really love the style. I like that rounded border thingy (don't know what to call it :wacky:) in the background and the colors are awesome! Not too much colors, which I like. The lighting effects are also pretty good and very nice usage of C4Ds in the background. Didn't care too much for the render though, but overall it's very good.

So in the end, I decided to go with 5.
 
OK, my vote has to go to #1. It looks like a lot of effort has gone into it, and Balthier seems to fit that the background of the sig. Also, it seems the perfect size for a signature.
 
I choose 3. Its simple but because of this it looks awesome.

I also really liked 1 because of the colors and the fact it is Balthier ^_^
 
I rather like 3, i was totally stuck for 1 and 3.

But i like 3 the most because it has very nice lighting and colour to it and just pwns :wacky:
 
My vote goes to number 4. I find it rather unique that someone used a different stock (M&M) then a typical anime or celebrity stock. Other than that it looks great.
 
I vote #1 for the following reasons:

The effects are impressive and match together.
The tag is colorful(something that I like).
It's blended well.
The text matches well with the whole tag.
 
Voting number 1. It simply has more life to it I reckon. It's got interesting colours and shapes.
 
I like 1.

The use of colours makes the image stand out and look more appealling. The overall effect is great and it seems to demand attention, this and I like Balthier.
 
2 GMV. Quite simply it's the most pleasing on the eye.

3 is nice, although I dislike the colouring.

#1 omg it looks like a ncie background, but then in the middle someone has just vomited everywhere. Balthier is far too light in comparison with rest of sig.
 
I'm going for 1 it has good effects, and colors even though I don't like colors much but still it's really good =D
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top