SOTW 217 Voting Thread.

[Warbsywoo]

The theme this week was a Picture Prompt:

Link.

Here are the entries I received:

1.)

2.)

3.)

+ Voting ends in 7 days
+ Entrants cannot vote for their own entries.
+ Although posting is not required for your vote to count, it is highly recommended.

 

[Tucker]

I vote for #3.
I appealed to me the most, and the gray blue and yellow fit nicely. It's very nice

 

[Sexy Beast]

I give my vote to #2. I thought it was the most appealing, and overall had the better detail.

 

[Raiiyokuu]

I give my vote to #2. I thought it was the most appealing, and overall had the better detail.

Quote for too lazy to give a reason.

 

[Squid]

I voted number 3. Its the only one that caught my attention out of the 3. 2 was my second choice but i felt that there was a little too much going on in the sig and 1 was a little too plain, plus the pretty swirls in the sky didn't really suit it

 

[Sasuke-]

1. 3 -
This was pretty on the sleeve. This one is perfect, loved the text and the render, including the effects.
2. 2 -
Nice sig, but you can remove the scale-like things on it.
3. 1 -
Bowie is right, the swirls didn't suit it.

 

[Ladyvamptress]

I voted for #3 cause the focal is blended and the color and style appeal to me more.

 

[Steve-O]

Number 3 gets my vote great lighting the text suits the signature very well and the background like awesome....it blended in the best as well... Number 1 nice but the pattern doesnt really go with the image XD

 

[Kandy-Sugar]

I'm not sure I get the theme for this week but I'll still vote for the one that most appeals to me anyway.

I voted for #3 simply because it appealed to me the most.

Nice fitting colours and good lighting.

The text in the background looks neat and I like the font used for the main text.

Nice job overall. =)

 

[Lirael]

My vote goes to #3.

This sig is the most cohesive. It's simple, but everything goes together. The background and text work with the chosen render. I really like the background design, actually, with the texture and smaller, more subtle lines of text.

Sadly, I feel #1 doesn't work as a whole. For me, the text is a little big and too invasive against the calm background. This lack of cohesion is accentuated by the elegant swirls, which increase the overall calmness and of the background. However, I do feel the swirls could have worked had the text been more elegant and fancy! It's the text and effects that don't suit one another... The landscape could have been transformed to suit either theme on their own, but not both.

#2 is too cluttered (the larger render doesn't work for me :/) and the C4D is too obvious/hasn't been blended in. However, I do like the text and colour scheme.

 

[Big Casino]

Without a doubt number 2. Its defiintely the best in terms of everything imho.

Number 1 is my second choice....its actually really cool the more i look at it the more i like it. The vectors in the sky are interesting. Makes it somewhat more abstract which i like the colours though dont work so good.

3 isnt bad either but it needs blended together. You can see the render and the background and the text. It needs more to make it one whole image and stop it looking so layered.

 

[Warbsywoo]

Congratulations to Cid XIII-2 for winning this week's SoTW.

1.) Richard B Riddick
2.) Chloe Frazer
3.) Cid XIII-2

Thank you all for participating.