SOTW 209 Voting Thread.

SoTW 209 Winner?

  • Total voters
    19
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Warbsywoo

Warbsywoo

Hellodia.
Veteran
Joined
Apr 15, 2007
Messages
4,891
Age
35
Location
California
Gil
2
The theme this week is Mythology. Here are the entries I received:

1.)
f2l9br.jpg


2.)
pandorap.png


3.)
WEMxL.png


4.)
megaerapandorasotwentry.png


And the lone AoTW entry:

pandoraavv.png


by, uh, yeah. I'm not saying.

+ Voting ends in 7 days
+ Entrants cannot vote for their own entries.
+ Although posting is not required for your vote to count, it is highly recommended.
 
I voted 3. I liked both the sigs with that picture but I thought 3 added a lot more techniques to it and made it look a little prettier.
 
My vote goes to two. Although I really like one, I can't recognize it, so I don't know who they were trying to represent. I honestly liked how evil and blood thirsty they made it. So my vote goes to two for knowing the mythology. The coloring and lighting are really nice. Also the whole mystery of the sparkling and glowing from the opening of the box, which makes it seem like what's the last thing supposed to be trapped in there, hope.
 
I voted for #4, I love the warm colors and textures used. Out of all of them it looks the most complete.
 
I didnt think any of them were particularly amazing to be honest. No offence intended to anyone there. I voted 1. Mainly because i think the colours are very very nicely worked. Its bright in all the right places. The scan lines need to go though, or at least half the opacity and erase it over te wolf. Nice sig tho (y)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Six
I'm voting on #3.

I'm gonna agree on what Lewis said as far as the entries go, with no offense to anyone, but none stood out to me personally.

I thought one was too sharp, and the use of topaz could've been a lot less I think. I didn't think it worked well against the flat background.

Number two, is gorgeous, but when I saw number 4 and compared it doesn't look like much was done, (I can't know this, obviously, but it eyes that way) cept for lighting and text.

The same goes for number four, I can see little effects in there, but it just didn't stand out to me that much.

Because of that, I went for number 3. I prefered the lighting, the dept is good also, seeing the shadowing (I don't know if it was like that already, but the shadowing on the stock is great. I wasn't too fond of the text, though.
 
I do not like any of these very much, which sounds like a prickish thing to say. That's what I think though, so that's what I'll say. The easiest way for me to decide was to ask, if I had to choose what one would I use? The answer was the first one, so I voted for that
 
I voted for #1.

Love how crisp and bright it looks. Scan lines look good but I think it would look better if they were a little more dull. I love the creature in the image too.

Awesome work otherwise. Definitely stood out the most to me. =)

Great work to everyone else too. =)
 
I voted for the first one purely for the fact that it stood out out of the others, and to me, it had the most depth. with the great lighting, and somewhat eye-popping colors. so, yeah voting for #1. :3
 
I'm going to say 1. The only reason is it looks very professional when compared to the others. I'm not saying the others were not good, it's just that Number 1 has a sort of finished quality that makes it stand out above everything.
 
Like a few other people said.. not any offense at all but none of them really stood out for me, in the end I went for number 1

f2l9br.jpg


because I think the lighting was much better than the rest also i think it had more effects than the rest of the signatures, the only thing that needs improving is that the signature is a bit too sharpened for me that needs toning down a bit :P
 
Congratulations to Raul (Ryuu) for winning this week's SoTW. :jay:

1.) Ryuu (Winner)
2.) Dragon Mage
3.) Draklor
4.) Megaera

AOTW Winner: Dragon Mage
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top