Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
LennethValkyrieSignatureMinusBorder.png


7/10

Let's start off with the size, unless you're doing a LP (Large Piece), I suggest to not make signatures really huge.

I'm liking the colors you used, they're subtle and it's not too bright. I also like what you did with the text.

Idk, it doesn't seem like there was much done to this piece. It looks just like a cutout for a wallpaper.

​
 
@Kyoshiro

Well, everything was self made using that one render of Lenneth - and Photoshop CS5.

@ Your stuff

Avatar: 8/10

This one has a rather surrealistic feel to me. I'm not sure what character is this, so I'm not sure if that partial face there is as it is, or intentional. That mask like black on the face looks like it was drawn there, lol.

EDIT: Well, dumb me, I guess considering the outline on that mask, it's obvious is was part o the character. Still don't know who he is though.

That, and the color strokes at his mouth area seemed somewhat random. I'm not so sure if it went well, overall, but I thought it would look the same without.

Signature: 10/10

Love this one. Was that C4D or something you used? I remember seeing the request thread or something for this particular piece... This was the third image, if I remembered?

It didn't look like there was much change, if I'm not wrong in saying, save for that making the guy brighter, and effects. Just those mix alone made the image really epic. Something I must work towards.
 
I'm loving that avvy. It's simple, and easy on the eyes. 7/10

Sig 1 - Lighting is nice, but the BG seems poorly-put together tbh. Could use some depth, too. 6.5/10

Sig 2 - It's nice, and the bg is great in depth. Foreground effects could be a bit better. 7.4/10
 
9/10 for both the sig and the avvy.

I'm not going to hate on the fact that the avvy is a crop of the sig because I like the fact that they match each other. I like the use of light to focus on the image itself...and the use of the darkness as well...it makes everything look tastefully done.

I'm not going to pretend I know who it is who is the sig, but his facial expression is something else :gasp:
 
At first I was going to rate the set 8/10 but it gets a 9/10 now because it grows on me.

I like the lighting, and the colours of the set suit Noctis well, the cropped point of the avi is good. The effects in the sig are pretty nice too.

The critique I have is mainly the text, the mixture is nice and I like the font on the LOVE part, but the other bit is hard to read, I also think it could have been placed to the left instead of where it is, as it throws the effects of the sig a little.

The border is a nice finishing touch, it's very good :)

EDIT:
Stella Nox Fleuret said:
I'm not going to pretend I know who it is who is the sig, but his facial expression is something else :gasp:
Click to expand...

It's Gerard Way from My Chemical Romance :)
 
8/10 for the avvy I like the colors on it (blue and black are my fave color). But you've lost two marks due to that guy hurting my eyes :wacky:.

Sig 1 - 9/10 for the same reasons above, and an extra mark for the beutiful effects on it.

Sig 2 - I don't like, its a bit too cheesy and I dont understand it's purpose.......cant get much lolz from it :/.
 
DS you got a new set :awesome:

I'm not a personal fan of lightning...but the set makes her look very pretty. The effects aren't overpowering and tastefully done...and the colors are very vivid and nice-looking. The dark background allows for the focus to be on Lightning's face.

8/10 for the set :ryan:
 
Considering the fact that the avatar appears to be a simple crop of the signature... Just consider the score for the signature similar to the score for the avatar.

This signature is cool! I like the effects, and the text is nice! Is that a chiasmus I see in the second line? I think if the background behind Noctis was made into the same color as with Stella's background, or for the reverse, it would make the signature look a lot nicer than it already is!

9/10!
 
Avatar: 5/10 it's a perdy butterfly but it's not really anything special. Still nice and fits your theme :)

Signature: 7/10 I like that blood splatter effect and the lighting, it needs something more, not really sure what though, maybe a border? Or to be a bit brighter?
But overall it looks nice still :D
 
Avatar 7/10

The avatar is too simple. It needs more colors and some effects on it.

Signature 9/10

It has great colors, well blended and nice border lines.
 
Avatar-7/10
Similar to sig but I still like it!

Sig 1-10/10
Sig 2-10//10

Both are really good. Colors used nicely and the caption fits nicely with the bg. Honestly I find no fault in them! ^_^
 
Avatar 8/ 10 ! It's so cute and adorable, though Cloud's hair seems to fade in the background a little bit and his whole weapon isn't showing and is a bit cut off and it looks a bit odd. Apart from that it's very loving and cute ! :lew:

Signature 6/10. It's a bit small, and it needs to widen up a little bit. Also it's a bit strange how his legs and arms are disappearing. :gasp: Very beautiful though.:)
 
Avatar: 7/10
I assume that's Aerith with Cloud? I am okay with the pairing, but it looks too gloomy to me. Nevertheless, very nice drawing there.

Sig: 8/10
I like the brighter colours in contrast with the avatar. There's that vibrant vibe to this signature. I also like Japanese character designs. But perhaps it's a little too big?

(oh and as for my avi and sig, it's my first time making them using photoshop. It's not that good I think)
 
I'll try and go easy on you as it's your first sig Cid :)

Sig: 7.5/10

It's a really nice attempt I think, I reckon if the patterns were removed it would look a little better, but the lighting fits Noel perfectly here, nice use of text too, the only other thing I will say is that the characters need to be blended in with the background a bit more, but that comes with practise :)

Nice avi too! 7/10
 
I think I'll do this again since I have a new sig and avatar :)

Avatar-Well you don't have one! So I give you a ZERO! jk, I'll give you N/A
Sig- 10/10 I like the line-up of your sig, it's centered nicely. I like the shade of light on the Brendon pics, and I like the Noel sig. I also love Brendon Urie ^_^
 
Avatar: 6/10 It's a bit dull, and the bottom half looks faded.

Signature: 9/10 Really adorable it is! I love the picture used and the colours are really nice. The text is pretty but a little hard to read :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top