Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avvy: 10/10 Death Note is the shit, and I will kill anyone who says otherwise.

Siggy: 10/10 Nothing wrong with it at all. :D
 
Avvy: 9/10 It looks ominous ;D which makes it awesome.
Sig: 10/10 I love the red on it! Once again ;] Looks pretty evil.
 
Avatar: 9/10

I really like the style. The text is very well worked and there is a clear focal point. It isn't filled up with too many effects and generally looks great!

Signature: 4/10

I don't think the image used is the best one. It looks like it would be very difficult to work with. Also, the stars don't seem to fit well. They look like they just been slapped on. The text looks good but isn't positioned all that well. The colours used do look good however, and I like the cloudy and dreaminess of it. That really brings out the emotion in the stock.
 
Avatar 5/10 - A face with a name on the side. Nothing to it. Vibrant colors on a white BG give it the 5.

Sig 10/10 - Thanks to the blur you gave it a depth which turned out to be awesome. I also love the render you used. To sum it up: Awesome.
 
Avatar: 7/10. It's got just a dot and ahhhh after it. Not saying it's bad but it could use a bit more :)

Signature: NOCTIS!!! 10/10. He's one of my favorite characters and I love the little fade you have on the bottom. It makes it a little mysterious and the green and black go well together.
 
Avi - 8/10 - Its interesting, i love anime avatars, whoever made it good work:D

Sig - 9/10 - I gave it a nine only because your announcing to the world that you are my stalker. As for the picture, im not too sure on it, Its a nice idea, but its not detailed enough...

<3
 
Avvy: 10/10 - I love the concept that is set up in the avvy. You have the word "hope" next to a human skull. Obviously the human has no hope, but that's what attracts me to it. :D It's somewhat deep if you think about it.

Siggy: 10/10 I love siggies that look like that. Also, it has the same hope concept that is in the avvy, which I like. Hey... wait a minute. *Looks at avvy and sig* I see what you did thar. XD
 
Avatar: 7 Its just a crop from the same pic that I used for the sig :P But since it is Touhou and the quality looks great, I give a 7 :grin:

Signature: Not sure if I can comment on my own work, but I give my siggy an 8. I may have went over board with the splatter brush and I could have moved Remilia a bit more into the sig. I could have made the sig a tad darker and more foreboding too :hmmm:
 
Avatar - Nice colors, lighting, and lettering 10/10 awesome stuff.

Sig - 9/10 and only because the lettering is a bit off, other than that it's awesome. The depth, and colors were the two elements that you nailed perfectly.
 
Avvy: 7/10 I like it, the colour scheme and brushes work well, but the border should go the whole way around

Siggy: 7/10 Its way to bright. The brushing looks kinda weird and the uneven border is...too uneven
 
Icon: 9
Banner 2: I give it a 9. It looks cool but somethings missing. Maybe not enough focus on him.
Banner 3: 8
I like the blendy effect, but he looks like he's blending into the background. It's still good, though. :3
 
Love it!! I like the size of the image as its alot clear and crisp. Nice image chosen of Ezio in action and the good old AC quote there. Nice text used and shadow effects also. Its eye catching and I love it.

10/10

As for the avatar, its a good cut from the sig, maybe add some text or a brush? Otherwise, not bad!

7/10
 
Avatar 7/10 it's missing something...

Sig 8/10 I like it but I'm confused as to what's going on. I can barely see what Spawn's doin...
 
Avvy: 6/10 It doesn't bland well

Siggy: 7/10 Kudos for trying to make Sephiroth the Focal. Text is good, but could use improvement
 
Avi: 10/10 Looks great. The color is vibrant and looks cool. Roxas is well put in and the blue eyes to go with the blue background looks great

Sig 1: 9/10 Everything is perfect except for the render placement. She is blocking a crucial part to the background: The clocktower. If she was moved slightly to the right, it would be perfect. The colors are great and the lighting rocks

Sig 2: 9/10 Looks great. Could be a little brighter, but thats really all thats wrong. The focal is well placed and the colors are excellent. The lighting would have brought out the colors more, but its not too bad.
 
Avatar: 9/10 Very bright

Sigs: Both get an 8/10 because they both kinad shine a little too much. It kinda hurts my eyes for staring too much. Maybe if you toned it down a little and keep Avi shiney? btw I love Lelouch! I wanna see more of him in siggy!
 
Avvy is good, could use a border though 7/10

Siggy could use some improvement, for future reference don't use 2 renders. I like the idea of putting those pics into his cape, bu thats all you really need. Size down the text a bit and use effects. Not a bad effort though 6/10

Also, try experimenting with different coloured backgrounds
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top