Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avatar: 8/10
The effects are very nice and colorful, its always eye catching. =) Its very nice, though perhaps a little too crowded to be an avatar?

Signature: 8/10
Its very simple, the effects are humble and its very pleasing (I like dark colors) thought maybe it could have had a little more going on, maybe some text would have helped. The image it self might be a little blurry, but its fine either way. =)
 
Avatar - 7.5/10, I love the colors and the simplicity of it. ^_^ The lighting is nice, but I think it could use a little more contrast, or sharpen it a bit, it looks to soft. :)

Sig 1 - 9/10, I know it's a set with your avatar, but for some reason, I like it better bigger where you can really see the lighting and the background. This is not as soft as your avatar, the lines are grainier (which I like) and sharper.

Sig 2 - 8/10, colorful. =D Nice and simple. I like the lighting and the effects, makes the character look like there's some kind of aura around him. x] It just looks really nice.

 
AV: 7/10
I like the bright colours and the positioning is very good as well. I would prefer it if it was a little bit cleaner but that's just me. Very nice :)

SIG: 6/10
I like how the sig has a dreamy feel to it, it works well with the theme in mind. The glowing 'things' are effective and well placed IMO. My eyes are, however, being drawn all over the place by the brightness so perhaps a focal point would be nice by editing the lighting. Also the text was a little hard to find. The font used is good and the blur behind it is a nice touch.

KIU :)
 
Avy: 9/10
I love the border. And I can see a little bokeh effects down in the corner, so thats cool. I dont really like all the colors though.

Sig: 7/10
First, its huge. The text doesnt really blend in. And idk if this is just me or not, but the girl looks kinda stretched. She might not be, though. Though the effects are awesome. I love how you used vector and grunge. and the girl blends pretty nicely. Good lighting.
 
Avatar - 7/10. It's very nicely made, but it's a little too harsh, I'd tone down the colours a little bit to make it better, and as always, I think white borders just suffocate avatars.

Signature - 8/10. Very nicely made. I love the colours and the blending here. I think it needs some text and a border to complete it though, but it's very nice :yay:
 
Avatar - 8/10 I love the colours, Its ver vibrant and it stands out.

Sig 9/10 - Absoloutley brilliany, Edea really stands out, again it is very appealing to the eye.
 
Avatar: 5/10

It's definitely my own opinion here, so don't get offended.

Perhaps your intent is to follow yellow and red for the color scheme of fire, in general. That's a possibility I don't know about, but I think it's really overdone for the image there. Cloud now looks like some yellow demon with red eyes, staring at your username- which can be mistaken as Starrive. R looks like V, and the top part of F is missing. Must be the fonts.

I think if you brought down the word, it would be better. More distinct, at least. As to Cloud, I think toning down the color would make it seem nicer.... It just feels weird no matter how many times I look at it.

Signature: 7/10

Looks good to me. Maybe, except for the fact the wings look a little off. Perhaps this could be resolved by pushing the image of Cloud slightly to the left...? I don't exactly like the sudden split in the image into another color though. Makes the image feel strangely disproportional- once again, to me.

(I'd like to say, I suck at making signatures, so there is little credibility in my comments.)

----

Speaking of which, like I said above, I suck at making signatures. So, I do not have a signature at present, and am in the process of requesting one. I suppose you can rate the words though.. :P

Really, I'd like to see how my self-created avatar is rated. So, bombs away!
 
Avatar: 5/20
Bad quality. Is it saved as a jpg? Text and background are alright. Border is fine. Maybe it should be rounded on the outside too.

Sig: N/A
 
8/10
Nice effects, seems alittle empty. Maybe a red gradient on lighten on your focal point would make things pop out and better. C:
 
Avi: 9/10 Wow it's rly good, love the colour scheme and the girl in the middle :)

Sig: 9/10 It's a bigger version of your avi, but that didn't matter. Only thing I would change is the black border. KIU :monster:
 
Avatar - Not much to it, but I can respect the basics. 6/10

Sig - good effects, not at all perfect but decent. 7/10
 
Avvy;

I think a border that stands out is needed... White perhaps. It looks kinda edgy. 6/10

Siggy;

A bit too huge for my likings. I'm not too fond of te text, though the colours match in this sig. Maybe if Ifrit was faced into the other direction and the text a bit closer it would've worked a bit more... 6/10
 
I like what you've done with your avatar... but I feel like it's missing something. 7/10

I love the rustic colors of your signature.. And it suits the girls solemn expression. 8/10

(About mine, I know it sucks... its my first one. Please be honest anyway!)
 
I've seen worse from a first. Ha, rhymes! *Ahem* anyway. Its pretty blah in general. Even if you were going for a gray theme, a little extra variety could have been used besides a couple black splotches. The background could be better too, if you have photoshop I'd recommend downloading some brushes online. You cut Tifa's stock pretty well, but the stock should blend in with the rest of the sig as best it can. Try to rub out the sharpness around Tifa. Just softening the edges of the stock can help a little bit. The icon is just a cut out of the sig. Try and make it a little different than just a cut out, add in your username or something like that.

I'd rate it a 2/10, I'm sorry! Keep trying, it takes time. Usually a lot of it. The more you understand the program your using as a whole, the better you'll get.
 
Avie: 10 I like how bright it is in contrast to the banner, its cool to see non-matching icon/sig sets and the person in it looks cool all in all The whole set is really good.

Sig: 10 :P
 
Avitar: it's impressive, love the use of colour and the background, Username is also incorporated well 8/10

Signature: Impressive sig too, good blending of colour and the Background is cool to, again your username is incorporated well, i like it. 8/10
 
I'm not gonna rate the PS3 thingie, since it's not a custom made signature xD

Avatar - 8/10. I love the colours here, and the blending. But while the text is very well done, I don't think it's necessary in the avatar, as it pushes out the focal too much.

Signature - 9/10. I love it. Very nice blending and colours. The text is done nicely, but maybe awkwardly placed. I love the left hand side too, it makes it very distinctive. :yay: Good job!
 
Avatar - Love the way that its black and white and there is a beam of light - 8/10
Sig(s) - LOVE the text on both of these, there close to the render and a good use of colour. I adore the second sig, its lovely and bright, also eye-catching - 10/10
 
avatar=7 unique coloration for cloud but the upper-left is kinda blank to me

sig=9 love it, the feathers r awesome and squall ftw!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top