Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avi: 7/10.
Its nice and simple I'd say, nothing to complicated and easy to use an avatar. =) Thought the quality of the image it self might be a little low.

Signature: 6/10
Its a very nice concept, love is always a good concept I'd say. But the image it self needs works as to the way it looks. Perhaps a little more color a few effects here and there? Though the hearts look very nice. xD <3
 
Avatar: 9/10
I'm a huge Zack Fair fan xD
The swirly border in the bottom corners are nice and effective. But the lighting effect that comes from the upper left is a bit much? Anyways, the colors are still nice ^^

Sig: 7/10
That's one mysterious looking dude. xDD Now, in this one, I really like the lighting effect, adds a very, VERY nice touch. =)
 
Avvy: 7.5/10
Like it, but you need to work on the border aand the text a bit, it looks too sharp

Siggy: 9/10
Love it, just wish it was smaller
 
Avatar: 8.5/10
I like it, but your chosen stock in conjunction with your background honestly makes Aerith look more like Vaan, in my opinion. The background itself is actually pretty epic. Reminds me of like, pink versions of the trees or something in a dreamlike realm shown in Ookami, which was an epic game, btw. :yay:

Signature: 6.5/10
I don't really like it, actually. It seems to have been done with minimal effort. I see lots of lense flares, and the black text and chosen font is somewhat contradictory to the beauty of the amethyst color scheme and the penant featured. The purple lighting is actually pretty nice, though.

Time to shine, Yumiko. ^_^
 
Avi: 8/10 It was OK, thought the background didn't match, different colours maybe?

Sig: 8/10 Again, colours put me off, and the size bothers me a bit. Overall a nice set.
 
Sabriel:
Avatar=8.7/10
It is good, but maybe a little too far away. And the background could be bettter... Anyways, It's good.
Sig=8.7/10
Exactly the same, but with words. Still good though. ^_^
 
Last edited:
Avvy: 8/10 Wtf? lol its pretty damn awesome
Siggy: 8/10 Theres not really much to it. the gifs are cool, and that greeny-bluey thing is alright but realy, i dont see much.
 
Avi: 9/10 Can't really say much cos it's a butout of your sig.

Sig: 9/10 Nicely done, beautifully positioned and wonderful colours. I love the render and the text. It so matches.
 
Avatar: 8/10- I'm not sure who the character is, but my, is she ever cute. ^_^ I really love the background and effects behind her, but something seems missing from it. Not sure what though, so I am no help. Maybe it's... kinda blurry at the top? That might be my bad eyesight though. xD

Siggie: 7/10- Cloud and Tifa... the perfect match right there! I love the idea of the pink color wave and the blue one. The thing that kinda of irks me about it though, is that there is white around Cloud, and Tifa's picture is a bit blurred. There's also a speck of white on her face. Not sure if I like the random green on there either. Otherwise, I love the idea of it!
 
Avatar 8/10 effective use of colors, and the design is really detailed

Signature 1: 8/10 again, effective use of colors, nice design, and i really can make out who that is.

Signature 2: 9/10 DARK COLORS YAY! they blend really well, and they show off Sephy's personality pretty well.
 
Avatar: 3/10

The image is low quality and I can't even make out what it's meant to be to be honest. The text font isn't the best and is quite blurry too. There's also too much red and everything sort of blends into each other and not in a good way unfortunately.

Signature: 4/10

Same comments for the signature.

I would suggest finding better quality images and looking up a few tutorials.

If the image were better quality these wouldn't be so bad. They're simple and aren't overcrowded and the signature has a nice simple border.
 
Avatar: 7/10
I like the colorful nature of the avi and the simple nature of it, too. Like maybe it needed a simple border to draw more attention to the eye but perhaps it was better that way. Even if it doesn't have text, I don't think it needs it at all. Lovely. <3

Signature: 9/10
Again, move beautiful and vibrant colors, so beautiful and very eye catching. The images are adorable,, the love is clearly visible there and the text on each signature is amazing. The images have a very good flow and the lighting is perfect. The links you have there also add to the colorful nature of your entire signature and the clan banner, simple and beautiful.
 
Avatar: 8/10

I love this image of Zack and the detailed background surrounding his face is gorgeous!
The colours represent the feeling of this image well and the text is lovely.

The only thing I can point out is that Zack's face looks like it has some light shining down upon it. Maybe in the top left hand corner make it look as though the light source is coming from there?

The simple border rounds this off nicely. =)

Signature 1: 9/10

Gorgeous signature.

The colours are beautiful and the filters in the background look great!

The images are blended well and the lighting works fine too. The text is also done brilliantly.

I would suggest blending the black bit on the right in a bit more though. It kind of looks like it's sticking out.

Signature 2: 9/10

Lovely work on this one!

The colours are bright and lively and really works well with this image.

The bubble effects surrounding him look amazing and the smudgy background looks great!

The text is done really well, though I think it needs to be a tad more readable.

The half border rounds this one off nicely!

Well done!
 
Avatar - 9/10 Lovely. I really like the colours and how it looks so glossy and smooth.

Signature 1 - 8/10 I like it, but I'm not so keen on the text, it sticks out a little too much, very nice colours though.

Signature 2 - 10/10, it's perfect! I love the colours, the lighting and the blending. The text matches the signature wonderfully too ^^
 
Avi: 9/10 It's brill, but what's with the fade at the corner? No offence.

Sig: 9/10 The BG and the render was great, though the text could be improved, IMO.
 
Avatar - 5/10 Crop from your sig, and if it wasn't for your sig, I'd have almost no clue what hell your avatar is supposed to be given the resolution and location of the crop.

Sig - 6.5/10 Too "busy". The background colors look off compared to the image, and the text is difficult to read due to the colors as well. Again, too busy. Too much going on at once for its own good.
 
Avvy: 5/10 I cant see it well, its too small.

Siggy: 7/10 Too simple for my taste
 
Avatar:

Cute. It's clean and simple and very vibrant. The image is positioned well and the text is as well. Lovely border too.

The only thing I can suggest is to change the font. =)

8/10

Signature:

This one looks lovely. I love the brushes you've used and the blue and black look great together!

If it weren't for that huge patch of white on the right it would look fantastic in my opinion. It looks brilliant over on the left.

I just think that the white is just a bit overdone and that if you kept the same flow that you had over on the left it would look even better. =)

Other than that it feels very calm and relaxing. The flow of the brushes look great!

9/10
 
Avatar:

I love the colors and the lighting.

8/10.

Signature:

The composition is a bit off.
The lighting is a bit too intense and needs work.
Work on depth.
Bit plain around the focal.


6.5/10.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top