Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avatar: 10/10

Very nice avatar. I like the colours and the image is much clearer and sharper in this one!

The background looks lovely and the pink bar down the bottom looks great with the text within it!

Lovely transparent border too!

Signature: 7/10

I think that you should focus on one image in this signature. You need to establish a focal point and with two images it's nearly impossible to do.

Miyavi on the left also looks like he has some of the background detail covering his face.

I would suggest taking out the image on the right and moving the left one into the middle. This way the set has the same image and looks better. =)

Also too much text looks a bit messy. I would take out the Japanese script running down the middle and just leave the pink bar with text at the bottom to make it look neater.

Other than that keep up the good work. =)
 
10/10 for both. I can't say anything bad about them. Their really beautiful.<3
 
Your participation is appreciated but could you please put a little more effort into your rating posts? There must be something that catches your eye about each piece. Short posts/one liners border on spam. ^^ Thankyou.
 
Avvy: 10/10

I really like the colour scheme and the blurry text thing you got going on here. Link still looks like the focal even though he's on the side. Its a really pretty peice^^

Siggy 9/10

The colourscheme is good and the text is awesome, nice use of the uneven border btw, I just wish there wasnt so much black on the sides, maybe bighten it up a bit???

Anyways, nice job on both^^
 
Avatar - 8/10 I love it, it's very simplistic, but in a very effective way. Not a fan of the white border though. I prefer avatars to be borderless.

Sig 1 - 6/10. I like the background, and the colours used are very pretty, but I think the blending and the text could be a lot better, and the white border would look better black, imo.

Sig 2 - 7/10. I like it, but again, blending and text could be better. The blue hue around the text doesn't go with the rest of the sig. The sig is really pretty though, with a really nice background ^^ I think the white border works here, but Sora should be BEHIND it, not infront, as that just looks as though he's been slapped on top of a background.
 
Avvy: 7/10

I like the little lighting you have, its very simple, which is good. i would've said it would look nice with a border, but you dont like borders...other than that its good.

Siggy: 9/10

Verry pretty. I love the efects you put around the person, makes the person stand out. I really like the border and the text, it all goes together very well.
 
Avi: I think I know where you got that render from: it's ver cool and ver texturised. 9/10

SIG 1: Love the colours and the BG, but I think its too plain. 7.5/10
2: Now this is more like it! Ver perfect. Love the differeces between the BG and the effects. Well done!
 
Avy: I like the colour scheme and the clarity of the character against the background. however i feel a border would do it a lot more justice 7/10

Sig: I like this better than the sig and I'm really like the text placement, the blending of the character has been done really well and the border finishes it all off nicely 9/10
 
Avatar: 7/10
It's pretty good, the border helps. Borders are nice, but better when they are a little more elaborate. Compared to the picture, the border is too plain to me. The Star Wars font is a nice touch. ^^

Signature: 8/10
The border's kind of blurry edges works with the picture. But the trees in the background look kind of squished, and the lettering seems like it's not centered right - maybe if more of the lettering was on top of the white? Otherwise, very good! xD
 
Avatar: 8/10

Nice and simple avatar.

The placement of the image is well done and the Japanese text on the left looks rather nice.

The only thing that I didn't like about it was the border. It looked a bit sketchy/messy.

I usually prefer clean and simple white one pixel borders. That's just me personally though.

Other than that good work.

Signature: 8/10

The signature is nice and clean.

The image is placed well and the plain background works well.

Lovely text placement right near the main focal as well.

The colours work well together and I like faint writing over on the left of the signature. =)

But once again I'm not too fond of the border.

Other than that, great work. =)
 
Avatar-8/10

-I love the colors use for it. Simple, but still very nice.

First Signature-10/10
-Your second siggy is very pretty. I love how colorful it is and the brushes used in it are awesome. My favorite part of the sig has to be the text.


 
Avatar: 7/10
I think it would look better if the border was completely around the image, or if there wasn't a border at all. Would be cooler with some text, too. (But I like text anyway, so --) I really like the faint diagonal lines in the picture! Adds a nice effect.

Signature: 7.5/10
Again I think the border would look better around the whole image, or no border. Siggy has text - yay for text! The heart is a nice touch. I think the clearer image in the front (left) would be better if it either wasn't there, or if it was replaced with her in a similar but different pose or something that is the upper-half of her body...

Altogether it's a nice combo! ^^
 
Avatar: 10/10

This one is quite pretty. I really like the detail in the background and the lovely light blues and pinks.

The text is really nice and that little glow of light behind it makes it stand out. =)

I also like those little 'x's' running down the middle near the text.

Well done!

Signature: 10/10

I like the detail again in the background and the colours are also lovely.

The face seems a bit too big for the signature and I think that it would look better if you could see more of him, but that's just me personally.

Other than that I can't find any flaws. =)
 
Avatar - 10/10. Wonderfully cut, I love the colours especially.

Signature 1 - 7/10. The background's a little too harsh for my liking, and it obscures Yuna's face a little, the text is sorta hidden too. It's nicely made though, it just needs some tuning.

Signature 2 - 10/10. Coco's outdone herself here, it's lovely. The colours and the blending used are perfection. I like the text too. Only thing I'm not keen on is the white border xD
 
Avi: 9/10 You gotta love the BG with the red glow, but I think it's too empty TBH.

Sig: 10/10 This is so more like it. Love the BG here, there's more brill effects and the red glow, text is perfect. Well done!
 
Avatar: 9/10
Very good, the only real problem I think is that since the image is so small, it's a little pixel-ated. It would be cool if there was some text somewhere, too - or a border. But I like texts and borders too much, so that's just me.

Signature: 9/10
The cool swirly effects, heart, and the two cool-looking texts make up for the little pixel-ly picture. But it's kind of hard to read the texts - the first one I can make out, but I can't tell what the bottom one says. Still looks cool though!
 
Avatar 9/10

Sig 10/10

The avatar seemed kinda rushed, but other then that pretty good.
As for the sig I can't find any flaws.
 
Avatar: 5/10

It's a bit plain. I like how the background is the same colour as the forum skin though. It would look more like part of the forum skin if Seymour was blended in more though and looked less squarish around the edges.

The text is a bit off. Another more simple text would look better and in a less harsh colour. But I would add any text to this one personally as it'll just look like it's floating there considering that Seymour is meant to look a part of the forum skin and all.

Signature: 5/10

It's simple and not overcrowded but there is too much text.

They are placed rather oddly as well. Choose one line of text and erase the other and place the one you keep on a horizontal angle and it will look much more appealing in my opinion.

Also the green and red stroke around the text looks a bit too much. Keeping the text simple always looks better in my opinion.
 
avatar = 9/10 well cut, simple background is made up for by coloration tho

sig = 10/10 simple and unique with brilliant anc vivid coloration, good shot of character
 
Well the avatar is alright, the problem with it is that it's on the blurry side. The background around it is a cool looking green snake effect, and the guy is outta focus and it's hard to tell who it is[in my opinion...]

5/10

The signature is mine, so I couldn't really judge it fairly, but I could say that it's one of my more impressive works. Someone else has to judge his sig and mine. Sorry...but I give my sig a

8/10
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top