Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The avatar is quite nice, simplistic and warm everything just looks as it should here, the subtle pattern in the background, the positioning. First class work right there

There is no point in trying to rate the signature, this kind of piece should be the new standard for 10/10 ratings
 
Avatar: 7/10.

I like the fact that when people have a set, the avatar is an actual 'crop' of the signature, that way it compliments each other. It doesn't have to be boring because you can mess with placement, so my rating is based on the signature as a whole for the avvy.

Signature: 8/10.

I'm not the biggest fan of the grainy look it has, but I love the blue orb, the border, and the rich colours. I also would like to compliment Ewan on making one person the focal while there's another one behind him. Not too certain on the cursive text, but the colours are great. :ryan:
 
Avi: 6/10 While I'm a fan of most black and white avis the effect isn't really doing much for me. I think if it was kept in color or if it showed a bit more color it could be more effective. The crop however is perfect.

Sig: 8/10 I like the stock and the blue glow effect actually really brings out the Joker :P I love the effects of the lines going diagonally and the text is very well placed. One thing that does bother me though is the little white specks everywhere. I think the image could have done with less of the white specs all over the image. Good sig.

Edit that was for Licky but now I'll do Kira's since she beat me to it XD

Avi: 8/10 You really know how to make Haley the star of your sig sets ^^. I love the stock with the purple color but it seems like it's missing something. I'm not saying it's missing a lot but for some reason I think it needs like a tiny splash of more color or a small black border to just make it perfect.

Sig: 9/10 I really think this is one of the better Haley sigs you've made. I love the text, I love the purple orbs that glow just right, I love the crazy effects going on at the bottom of the sig and the squiggly line and I love the black and white effect because it seems that the main image being black and white hasn't given the sig a dull feeling for me and that's rare. The only reason I put a 9 is because the space in the upper right part of the sig felt empty and smalls things like that bother me. Otherwise it's yet another amazing Haley set for Kira :yay:
 
Last edited:
Avatar: 6/10. a little weird and grainy and a little dull but it doesn't look that bad :)

Sig 1: 7/10. although this one is also grainy I actually think it suits the image a little better :) I think some text would have done it more justice.

Sig 2: 8/10. I like the length of it and the border is interesting with the one side missing. I like the background and the picture but once again some text would be nice.
 
Draco Malfoy said:
Avatar: 6/10. a little weird and grainy and a little dull but it doesn't look that bad :)

Sig 1: 7/10. although this one is also grainy I actually think it suits the image a little better :) I think some text would have done it more justice.

Sig 2: 8/10. I like the length of it and the border is interesting with the one side missing. I like the background and the picture but once again some text would be nice.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I suck with text, so I wanted to keep it out for the sake of text possibly ruining the tag. :lew:

Since there's no avvy, I will rate the sig XD

I love it. The colors are very appealing, and while I don't like the text that much, it has a very nice look to it. 8/10
 
Avatar 9/10

It looks great! I like the colors and the effects used in it. Inyuasha (I hope :sad3) looks truly fierce with that red color added to his eyes. Really fits as a Avatar.

Signature 1 8/10

I like it. The colors are great and the image is fantastic. It seems a tad too sharp in my opinion, but it still comes across looking excellent. I love the effects, which add immensely to the depth.

Signature 2 7.5/10

I like this one as well. It is really colorful and the effects are diverse and spread about. The thing is that the heartless's sword creates another focal, and that diverts my attention. I want to look at the heartless itself, because of the beautiful color and effects, but the sword is there. Otherwise, fantastic job!
 
The avatar is okish I guess, Sora looks like he has just kind of been transposed onto a background though. The font isn't particularly fun either, not a bad avatar just no great shakes.

The right side of your signature is prtty great, vibrant fun and it really suits the main render. I hate the left side to be honest, it looks like a weird Wizard of Oz type thing. I like the phrase you used, but the font has no blending or design
 
Already rated your set before.

I give the complete set an 8/10. I think the colours used, and the text look great, but as I said I'm not a big fan of the grainy effects. I forgot to mention in my previous judge post, that I love half borders like that. :ryan:
 
Not sure if I rated yours, but oh well.

Sig: Love it. The black and white with the touch of purple works really well. A little to contrasty on Haley's skin, but still great nonetheless. 8/10

Avatar: Just love this. Simple image with simple lighting is always win for me. 9/10

9.5/10 overall. :)
 
Sig/Avy 1: It's quite nice. Everything circles around a nice theme and the effects are not overpowering. I'm a little confused about those "bubbles" but I won't complain too much. 7/10

Sig 2: I think the blending of the stock is good but it's a bit hard to tell because the whole thing has a "faded" look. Plus it's too big for my tastes (I like 'em smaller) and doesn't have a border (I love borders). 6/10
 
I quite like the avatar actually, even though Lucas is the superior character by a long chalk.It could be bigger, but I see you are 81 posts short of being allowed a 150 x 150 pixel avatar. Not really sure what to think of the sig, it's so very small and just appears to be a fractal. Nice enough fractal from what I can see
 
I'll rate yours as a set, I've already told you how nice it is, 'I' did a really good job with it!! The picture is really good and I love the effects!!! 10/10
 
You need an avatar :mokken:

:wacky: Of course I always love Lew's sigs. I hardly ever see them on the forum but when I do I can always decipher they are his. They usually have an awesome stock photo that is very clear and the colors that he uses are always very vibrant. It looks like he's used a few effects in this one but I really like them and I don't think they are overly done at all. I don't know who the guy is but he's kinda-ish cute too. Very nice...10/10.
 
I'm so jealous of Ewan's skills. :sad2:

I love the mystical feel for this, but just for some reason I can't help say that the effects themselves don't fit Stella all that much. To me, she feels more of a dark and mysterious kind of character, and while some bits are exactly that in the tag, just the way the lighting is makes it too magicy. With that being said, it's purrdy, and that's all that matters, methinks.

9/10 for the sig, and 8.6/10 for the avvy

8.8/10 overall for the set.
 
The first signature is very indistinct, it's like trying to look at the edge of a murky lake with your head underwater. Dull greenish lighting with odd outcroppings of rock, that is what it looks like, in my opinion. Not necessarily a bad thing, if that's the look you're going for. Considering I don't know what stock you used, maybe it's just the image that is indistinct. It reminds me a little bit of the thing from Alien wearing a person's face. The text is very good though, so there's that

The second piece is much better I think, still it's hardly Jack the Biscuit. I like the effects around the image, but the bottom right and upper left are very boring. The text is mundane at first glance, and only a bit more exciting when I look closely. Wasn't her name Halibel? That seems like horrendous Engrish but I dunno

The avatar is just a crop, so yeah
 
You again :lew:

So I see you have another new set so here goes ....

For the avvy: I can't say that I am caring for it too much :( The quality is a bit blurry for me. I do like the image, I just think I'd like it a bit better if it was clearer. 7/10. Also I'm not digging how the sig and avvy don't match...but thats just me being matchy matchy.

For the sig, I honestly have to say this is probably the best of yours that I've seen so far. I like the lighting (almost moon-like in a way) that focuses on the girl while the rest of the sig is kept pretty dark. I also like the image that you used, its quite clear and cute. So for this I give a 8.5/10.
 
Okay first time doing this as I currently have a constant sig instead of a rotator (for maybe a day or two) :gasp:

Very simple and I like the black and white over the stock. The red light adds a nice touch to it, and the text looks really good. Although you can't see it on the black theme, I like how the rounded edges were done. I rarely see them done well. 8.5/10 :D

Avatar is just a crop of the original it seems but it still looks good :P


Sexy Beast said:
Not according to Bleach wikia. :hmph:
Click to expand...

Harribel would be the direct translation, but the Japanese don't have the "L" character in their alphabet (which is ironic for the character L from Death Note :wacky:) so it's replaced with "r," so it would be Halibel.
 
Avatar: 7/10 - Just a cutout.

Signature: 7.5/10

Right away, I'm not a big fan of the whole white emptyness on the right side, but I see what you were going for. The render needs more blending and you can do that by placing over a gradient over the render. The Piece would have look better if the scanlines were over the render as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top