Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
^
avatar 2/ 10 Sorry. Oh man I feel like a huge asshole. But I think that the animation is a little basic, and not drawn realistically or with much detail.( then again, same with the banner I have ) It would be nice to see his/ hers eyes open too.

Signature 5/10 The wolf is drawn so much better. It has more style and detail that the icon is lacking.
 
Avatar 8/10 - I like the colours and the image of it.

Signiture 8/10 - I like it but I think you should move the phase slightly more to the left as I can't see the rest of that R =D
 
Damn, same problem as poster above. xP

And Paradise, a very good friend of mine (Kyo Wolfe) made the full image that I cropped that from for me for an (early, as it turns out) birthday gift for me, and I love it, so that hurts... ._.

There is a link to the full image in the underlined "this" under my signature pic. If you'll see that, you'll know his eyes are supposed to be closed, he is relaxing in a cool pose, waiting for something to happen...

And it isn't supposed to be realistic, it is sort of Manga style. =P
 
I'll rate Ex-Soldier Cloud since I already rated Wolfe's and Licky's set.

Sig: I like the animinated text, but I'm afraid that's all it has going for it. ): 5.9/10

Avy: I like it. the colors go with the original image. 7.5/10

Overall: 6.7/10
 
Both are getting the same rating and comments because yeah. It seems really messy and grainy, really just a whole host of other negative adjectives too harsh to put down. I see what you were aiming for, so just keep plugging away because it has a lot of potential if you master that style.
 
^ Hahaha, revenge time :awesome:

/ rubs hands evilly.

Avatar 7/10 I like it, but the background is a bit strange and off, you can just see chucks of Batman and it looks a bit odd. Apart from that, nice !

Signature/ banner 9/10 I love it, it's brilliant ! Though Batman's head's missing makes the picture a bit off. :martel:

@ Crimson Wolf. I'm sorry ! I feel really mean !! :sad2:
 
Avatar - 7/10, nice and simple, don't know what else to say about it xD

Sig 1 - 8.5/10, don't know the characters, but I'm really liking the colors and the effects in this one! It could maybe use some lighting effects or maybe some flecks of color with "Lighten", but it's still really cool.

Sig 2 - 8/10, once again, REALLY cool effects and colors! I'll give the same advice as in Sig 1, with the lighting and color and such. This is very nice, and I like the background a lot :)
 
The avatar is pretty damn good even if it is only a cropping, it would be better in a larger size, but using my observational skills I see you are limited to 100 x 100. I really like the signature, a nice simple look with a very nice render. It just comes together really well as a set

8/10 if you want a number or some shit like that
 
This thread again. :ohoho:

I'll comment on the aesthetics of the set as a whole, since the avatar is just a chunk of the sig itself. I like the black-and-white effect, though.

I find the sig to be well-done as well. I'm not a huge fan of non-traditional borders, but that's just a matter of personal taste. The effects are nice and not overpowering (as many sigs tend to be), and due diligence was taken to make Joker the focal point of the image.

9/10 or whatever
 
Avatar: 5/10. Small image of a character from a video game series I have never played, doesn't do too much for me, but I respect that he has been in every Smash Bros. game to date. :P

Sig: 8/10. Seems a shame to not rate it higher, but it suffers to the point of being short true greatness due to it's unfortunately small size...
 
Avatar: 4/10 bit blurry and boring and very amani. I can't even read the text :(

Sig 1: 7/10 I like this sig, the colours are perdy and i like the picture. The text is a bit plain though and it's really dull near the dogs head :(

Sig 2: 7/10 I love the picture in the middle and the cool fire flare really gives it a good touch, the text is lovely too, but the weird brown sides kind of let it down :(
 
Avatar: I dont see one but I'm sure your next one will be great ^^

Sig:10/10 I'm a huge fan of Lew's work :P The colors in the sig and the lighting are near perfection. I love the little bubbles of color the most :3
 
The avatar is a nice cropping of the image, not mad on the border though to be honest, was never a fan of that type of effect. The signature image is a nice one and though I am normally a fan of simplicity and minimalism, there is not much going on there. Decent set overall though I must say
 
Overall, my sig still seems to be more well than my avatar... But I love it, and more than anything I think that is what counts most. :D

Already rated user above's avatar and sig, but still wanted to post. >.>
 
Avi: 6/10 It's cute, but it's just a cropped pic

Sig: 6/10 I like the background, but the wolf isn't blended in and the text could use a bit of work, it's a little too bold.
 
Avatar: 7/10, it's really cute and I like the border but the pic could have been a bit better.

Signature: 9/10. I really like it!! It's super cute and the borders and colours suit it a lot! Also ash and pikachu are best!
 
Signature 10/10

I love the colors. the stock is so cool looking. I like all the multicolored vectors, as well, makes the plain stock really pop out and catch your eye. I'm not too fond of the square border that follows the whole sig but it's thin so it's okay. The font is so crisp and clean. and it's placed so perfectly too. The lighting is just superb. :ryan:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top