SOTW 68 Voting Thread

SOTW 68

  • Total voters
    25
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Daenerys

Daenerys

The Last Dragon
Veteran
Joined
Nov 26, 2006
Messages
11,178
Age
33
Location
Suburban hell.
Gil
1
The theme was tricky this week, which is why I think I've only got 4 entries D= The theme was non-rectangular ^^ And you have to post for your vote to count!

1)
Angel4.png


2)
doink2.png


3)
33x96he.jpg


4)
SOTW-1.gif
 
All great entries, but I like entry #1 the most. Its very well rendered/blended and the stock image used is great and so as the text, great work there. ^_^
 
Number 1 for me as well. I absolutely love everything about it, from the gorgeous stock, to the beautiful color, to the well-placed text. Fabulous job! to whomever made it ^^
 
Its between 1 and 3 for me, i really like number 2s idea but its a little messy round the edges. hmmm i guess il go with 3, its not quite parallel but i love the idea. The colours are bright and its totaly different from the others.
 
This was a bit hard because I really like #1 and #3 but I picked #1 because of the render being blended in nicely with the firey background and how nicely the text stands out as well.
 
I like 3 the best. It looks really nice, and i like the multiple circles thing going.
 
I picked number 3 cause it was the best in my eyes and it is quite simple.
 
i like them all. but i had to pick number 2, i love the way that the artist has superimposed the Tonberry's face onto the blade of what appears to be a tonberry's Knife, quite a good idea and it looks good.
 
I actually really like number 3 because of the final fantasy characters. I agree the circles are amazing for number 3. Number 3 gets my vote.
 
I have to agree with Amarant and go with #2, it is a neat idea for a sig, and to me, it is quite well done, reminds me of the Tonberry summon from Final Fantasy VIII. :lol:
 
I voted for 1 because the colors are really good and I like it how the girl sticks out a lot. But #3 was also good because it had multiple sutff and it matched because all of it was blue so they both were good.
 
#1 definitely. The shape, the colour, the image and the font are brilliant. I honestly can't pick a fault with it.

#2 would have been 2nd imo. The idea is brilliant and I was going to comment on the handle being tided up, but at second viewing it's obvious it's meant to be like that and done extraordinarly well. It's just unfortunate that #1 is so good.

#3, again the idea is really well thought out, my only problem is that ir seems more like 7 separate images rather than one whole sig.

#4, the idea is good. Congrats.
 
It is a toss up between One and Two for me... I really like the idea for Two but the fact of the matter is, it isn't very well done... So my vote goes to number One, it had good color scheme, good stock image, it isn't anything too special but its pretty good none the less...
 
I am really digging the first one really well blended and i like the oval shape, it gives it that creative, and unique look, whoever did it great job on that, you really deserve the attention that it could possibly get.

And the others weren't all that bad either i really liked number 2 and 4 as well but number 1 caught my attention the more. So great job to all of them..^-^
 
I chose number two because it has light and dark colors. I like how it is designed and the shape of it. The other ones are great to but this one is pretty cool.
 
Last edited:
1 gets it from me.

A VERY UNUSUAL TOPIC, although they did a great work that still fitted into the topic nicely. Well done.
 
My vote goes to number 1. The knife was really cool, but the edges could have been neater. I would have liked to see some kind of unnatural shape to number 1, but it was good all the same.
 
Number one as it just seems the most well done, concept wise though i would have said number two
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top