Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avi: 7/10

I like the background, but other than that it's a normal pic.

Sig: 8.5/10

Love the colour scheme, the focal points on either side are a nice touch, all the text is upside down though apart from about 3 phrases, it's a good effect, but can be quite confusing, and I'm not too sure about the pink butterfly, throws the whole sig off a bit, but I love the rounding off of the tag and the whole concept is pretty good, thumbs up from me :)
 
Avatar 8/10

I like it. The colors are vibrant and attractive and the picture is great. It seems a little too sharpened, but otherwise is very well done. And I love Persona 3 :x3:

Signature 1 6.5/10

I like it. The color is good enough and the placement is okay, but could have been better. The effects around the guy are very distracting and throw off the piece a lot in my opinion. And that black part in the the upper left corner does not fit at all. It is a decent tag, though.

Signature 2 8/10

I like this one. The colors are very fitting and correspond well to Megaman. I love the effects placed into the background and the signature is sharpened very well. The focal placement is done well, and the piece attracts the eyes. Well done! :awesome:
 
And that black part in the the upper left corner does not fit at all
Click to expand...

was part of the original stock; couldn't be helped :sad3:

I'll start with the avvy. Loving the half-border; it really fits. Colors are nice, and focal is clean and well-defined, I'm just not sure if the quality of the focal is the best. 7.8/10

The tag has good BG colors, and the effects are nice, but flow is a bit off imo. Those honey comb, brush strokes are nice, though. 7.8/10

Cloud is awesome :ryan:. 9/10
 
Avi: 8/10

I love the avi, like the effect in the background behind the focal, the only thing that gets me is it looks a bit pixelly in some parts of the focal.

Sig 1: 10/10

As a fellow MCR fan I love this sig, and contrary to what Nexas said I think the black part fits in well, you know like the colour Scheme of Gerard there, I love the effects and lighting you have there aswell, and I really can't fault this one!

Sig 2: 8.5/10

I love the colour scheme on this one, and the effects are good on this one.
 
Avi: 6/10 It's a sketch of Cloud....but not much else is going on there. It feels a bit bland and I can't help but think that something's missing from it.

Sig: 7.5/10 I think the concept is great but the one spot of blue kinda throws this one off for me. I think the blue could have been distributed throughout the signature? Light is blended with with opacity it looks like. The text is kind of bothering me too a bit. I think it might be placement of it that gets me. It's an overall decent sig ^_^
 
Sig: 7/10 I like how you changed the tints on the sig, but maybe did it too much with the face?

Avvy: 6/10 The colors looked good, but part of the hair looks messed up (unless it was meant to be that way) and the other colors look a bit choppy.
 
Avatar and sig are both an 8 because there are two men who look like they wanna kick my ass. Sazh looks like mr t fuck ya. No idea who the other dude is but he's pretty sweet.
 
Avi: 7/10

Basically a crop of your sig, but I like it, maybe a border could finish it off nicely.

Sig 1: 8.5/10

Timesplitters? Haven't played that game in a long time! (If my guess is correct that is)
I really like it, although that type of concept isn't usually my thing, it has been done very well, the lighting is well placed, the background and text are spot on, and the focal is blended in nicely.

Sig 2: 7/10

I like the border, and the way it has been made to suit Sazh's eidolon, however there are a few things I think could be improved, like the 2 focal points are kind of distracting the lighting is a little bit off, I can only just make out the Chocobo in his hair, but to others it may look like he has a weird haircut? And the flaming Sazh is a bit blurry. But overall it's not bad :)

EDIT: for cardiac kid..
 
@Joey The avy was meant to look that way :gonk: I wanted her hair and Bg to have some sort of effect and the colors to be contrasty/wildish feel. XD

Um avi is 6/10 like before. It's a nice pic but as I said before kinda bland.

Siggy: 7.5/10 I forgot to say that I liked Lights blending in with the sig and the border is interesting.....Maybe bump up the opacity of it a bit more?
 
Avatar - 7/10
Seems too cluttered with the special effects that you used. Plus, the size is a bit too stretched, height wise.

Siganture - 8/10
Nice and Simple, I like it. I'm just not too fond of the size and the fonts used. I care barely read, but on the other hand, you have some nice effects going on in there.
 
Avi: 6/10

A cropped pic, but with an overlay (?) and a nice border not too shabby!

Sig 1: 8.5/10

I love the effects of this one, I like the whole dark vibe it kind of gives off, the lighting and the background are awesome, would of voted in SOTW if you didn't get yourself disqualified :gasp:

Sig 2: 10/10

LOVE LOVE LOVE! Love the lighting, love the focal, love the text, love the background, love the border, it's amazing, really, can't fault it!
 
Set: 10/10

Very pretty and very unique. I like how much the yellow stands out. It looks like it'd be hard to work with and Kira did it beautifully.

Your Megaman(??) Sig: 10/10

Very very very very nice. I love it's peacock colors and the focus on the megaman character is perfect. There's no words or border, but this sig is so awesome it doesn't need any.

Very good job to both of you.
 
Avi: 8/10 I really like the pic actually! ^_^ I think the part in black in white at the top could have been in color or another shade or something but overall I love it ^_^

sig1: It's simple and clean. Cloud and Aeris are cool but I think alot more could have been done with it. 7/10

Sig2: AMAGAAAA KITTY!!!! Lol I love everything about this sig, even it's brightness and the kitty's almost creepy blue eyes!!!! The only thing I would say is that the borders on both sides seem too big, but other than that it's puuuuuurfect XD 10/10
 
Last edited:
Avatar: 7/10 colours look nice but isn't really eyecatching

Sig: 9/10 Once again I really like the colours, the girls are easier to see in this than the girl in your avatar. I like the little flowers coming off each side of the border :D
 
Icon: same as before.

Gaga sig: 9/10
Love the super glossy look it has, the focal on her is amazing. I usually don't like that type of font, but right in that place it looks brilliant.

You sig: 10/10
I just love the colors, there's no font or text but it doesn't need any. I just wish there was a border.

It's just purely amazing. <3
 
Avatar: I like the city lights in the background, they really capture the mood. 10/10

Sig 1 and 2- I'd rate them about equal because the colors really stand out and blare, the only complaint is that "This is the story of how I died" doesn't fit it very well. 9/10.
 
well i'm not much into the crazy sigs/ avatars... so i feel bad for whoever posts next
:biteme:

BUT...... for the one above me;

Avatar 9/10 - pure awesomeness. i like your style kid.
Sig 9/10 - verrry nice. super simple yet super sleek looking. props dude.

woulda given you 10's, but i dont think there is a way to say any sig or avatar is perfect ya know?

/forrealee
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top