Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avi: 7/10 Its nice, Roxas is awesome, but the Keyblades look a little out of place. :/

Sig:
Banner: 8.5/10 Very nice, but the text is hard to read
Other: The placement of the other links and such are a little odd, it would probably look better if you centered them.
 
Icon: 9.5
I love it. I like the background colors.

Sig: 13/10
Five extra points for Kirby! The stars in the background are perfectly placed.
 
Avy: 2/10

It's just a cropped image, nothing is really done to it =/

Sig: 4/10

Idk it looks like just the image again, but maybe the effects around the person were edited??
 
Avatar:9/10 Works great as an Avy

Sig 8/10 I like it better as an Avy. It works as a sig but it's kinda plain for me...
 
Avy: 6/10

It would look really great if you kind of toned down the keyblades, a bit too bold and makes Roxas look strange.

Sig: 9/10

You've really improved Oliver, it looks really good, I like the effects and the lighting is good too. But try and blend in the keyblades a bit more, it looks a bit too bold.



 
Avvy: 6.

Looks nice, but it's a bit light, I think the text could've used some work, but besides that, it's a fairly simple, and nice avvy.

Sig: 7.

Specially like this one 'cause it improved from your others (I know this isn't a valid point here).

I love purple, and the placement seems nice, text could use a bit of work again, but looks pretty aside from that. ^^
 
Ninja me ONE MORE TIME PEOPLE :rage:

Avatar = 7, simple, but for my taste, not enough added. Perhaps some contrast? something, sharpen the sheets, Idk...

Signature = 8, again good but not my taste really, so this is kinda biased I guess...>_< The text in the middle is rather hard to see for my eyes, but I can still read it. I dont know if the rose is in the stock but it a nice symbolic touch. The lighting is good too...
 
Avatar 7

It looks nice, but all that lighting kind of ruins it. It obscures the good parts of the avatar and kind of makes it hard to see. From what I can tell, it looks nice, just the lighting needs to be toned down.

Sig 8

It's a great signature. The lighting in this is very good and highlights the right parts in the signature. The focal is positioned very well, and in my opinion, the text is very fitting. I like the effects in the background , too.
 
Avi: 10/10

It's old Garland from FFIX! What I love about it is how eerie it looks - which is something you would associate with the character at first. I love what has been done to the lighting - it's not too dark or too light - either of which would obscure the eerieness of his face.

Sig: 9/10

It's a really good effort - and has paid off well! I like the stock you have used because of the awesome looking sword. It's interesting to see you use the background of water - something important when it comes to Tidus. The shining effects and the lighting above is rather clever as well. It is pretty indeed. The colour of the text is a little obscured though.
 
omfg valkyrie profile
xD I don't really like Hrist, but hey, it's Valkyrie Profile!
Avatar: 9/10
I like it, though the background could use some more... things >.>

Sig: 11/10
I can tell it's made by Ryan just by looking at it once. xD But that's not a bad thing! His sigs are awesome! The effects surrounding the render are awesome, but so is the background. And hey, it's Valkyrie Profile!
 
Icon: 10/10
I just LOVE LOVE LOVE it all. I have no idea who it is, but I'm a sucker for black and white.

Banner/Sig: 10/10
Love the placement of the render, it just pops. I really like the grunge-ish background, it goes really well with it all.

Sabriel did an awesome job on it.
 
Avy= 9/10
Siggy= 10/10

Avy: Gosh, you always make such awesome sets.O__O Anyways, I like the text in the avy. It's simple but still very pretty.<3

Sig: Love the picture you used for it, and I love the sketchy heart in the background. And chose a great quote for Cloud and Aerith. One last thing I forgot to put is that the rounded edge finishes the sig nicely. <3
 
Wow, someone as great as you complimenting my graphics? I'm so honored.

Icon: 10/10
I love the placement of the man, it fits very well. It leaves room for the eye-catching font to its right.

Sig: 10/10
I am absolutely in love with your sig. I am a HUGE sucker for black and white and those red glows just are the perfect finishing touch to it all. I really love that you put the stock in the banner twice, it's eye catching. The font is placed perfectly too. Great job!
 
I'll be nice and give ya 7.5 on sig and 7.5 on ava.

I mean, come on!! What wrong with Cloud's lips?! He looks like white-asian-black dude!!

Dun listen to me....Am an ass :gasp:
 
Yea, the art is weird, But still nice.

Icon: 7/10
Too blurry.
GIF: 10/10
It's funny but I don't get it at all.
 
Avatar: 8/10

Nice avatar.

The lighting is a little bit too dull though and it was hard to make out what I was looking at for a second, but other than that it's very nice.

Nice blending and I like the small text in between their heads. Very cute. =)

Signature: 8/10

Same thing again really since it's the same as the avatar. Lighting is just a bit too dull.

Other than that it's nice and simple. The border is rather unusual which is nice too see. Good to experiment. I like the rounded off edges too.

The font works in well with the feel of the signature too.

Great work!


 
^ *sighs* You got there before me. Looks like I'll start over.

Avi: 8/10

You've done an exceptionally good job with the lighting above Roxas. The background is rather nice as well. However, my only gripe are the keyblades in the foreground. I think it would look better without them because the keyblades don't look like they belong to the image as well.

Sig: 8/10

Like the avi, you've done a great job with Roxas, the lighting and the background. The white wisps of light against the dark background is really beautiful. Once again, I'm not too sure about the keyblades - or the text. I like how the keyblades extend out of the sig though.

Excellent work! ^_^
 
Avy-9/10
Sig-10/10
OMG! VP is one of my favorite games ever! Not a big fan of Hrist, but still, it's VP!
Okay, let me get back on topic here....

Avy- Love the pink background! It's the total opposite color for Hrist.XD I also like the c4d(?) used at the bottom of the avy and the border is a nice finish.

Sig- Whoa...I mean look at it! It's uh-mazing! I like how the c4d looks like bubbles floating about. The half-border is different, but in a good way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top