Serious A Day Out With The Ex...

Gingerbread Lesbian

Banned
Veteran
Joined
Dec 30, 2007
Messages
10,644
Gil
0
So some of you knew that I'd recently split up with my girlfriend after 18 months of a happy relationship so I'll summarize that before I go into details about what happened today.

Most important to note is that I love my ex, I count her as my first ever proper girlfriend that I genuinely "loved" for the simple fact that, she made me happier than anyone has ever done. More so than that, she's the one I think about every day and the one person who was my best friend at college and the one person I could turn to any time I needed someone, and this was the same from her perspective too. I was always there when she needed me from the time she got in an argument with her mother to when her granddad and baby brother died. I'm not going to into that because as you would suspect, that's heavily personal stuff but you can see where I'm going with that anyway. But, what I am most proud of is that, whilst we had friends who had relationship breakdowns through cheating and the likes, it made me feel happy knowing we weren't like that; we never even had an argument in the whole 18 months we went out.

It wasn't really until June that it started to break down when I found out she was "texting" someone else, I was assured though that it wasn't anything "overly bad" and in all honesty, I believed her and still do, the main gripe I had was the fact she knew I was pissed off and upset about it but when she got out of the car I thought it would be the last I'd see of her for 3 months so yeah, I cried. I'm not bothered about admitting that because she means the world to me, but I found out later that day she'd had a leaving meal and not told me about it but rung the person she was texting and asked him if he was going and the next day she was moving down here [to where I'm at university now] and I confronted her about it and she said she was sorry and that they didn't talk anyway and I believed her [and I do] so I thought to myself that we could have a fresh start and wipe the slate clean to just forgot what had happened and moved on. Relationships aren't always going to be a smooth ride, and I knew that, which is why I gave her the chance.

So a week on and everything was going great, it felt just like it did at the beginning again, and we both thought that. But then she went to Germany for two weeks to see her mother [moved with the army] who had given birth prematurely, and something just... switched off, with her. She came back and all of a sudden texts were few and far between and just straight up ignored, and this hurt you know, because I had no idea why. All of a sudden the coach I was going to get down to see her wasn't happening anymore and things drifted apart at a rapid speed. So one morning I rung her and asked what was up and she said it just didn't feel like the same anymore and that I sounded a bit sarcastic when I said I "Hoped she had fun" at her cousins party, bare in mind, if it did, it wasn't meant to. So a little later she text me saying it wasn't going to work anymore.

So we spent all morning texting each other, and I did at one point send a fucking huge 40-page text message; this is how much I cared about her. And I did say something that hurt, but again, this is heavily personal so I won't go into details, but bare the latter in mind because it's important for what happened today.

So moving on a few weeks, texts became more sparse and life moved on a little...

Fast forward to yesterday. I saw her for a little bit because we needed to talk face-to-face and she came to mine, and we did get to a point where she said she doesn't think it could work after what was said [insert earlier text message] but, I think this is important, she never said it as a certainty, she said it but almost came across as if she felt bad about it but remained adamant it couldn't work and that she could hardly look me in the face because of it [there is an extra point to this which I found out today] and time went on a little and things became a little more relaxed and we were just sat there and she let me play with her feet. This, sounds weird, but I find it important. Would someone who said they could hardly look you in the face anymore and say it could never work really let you play with their feet if they couldn't stand to look at you? Because the way I see it, I don't understand how that works and even at the time I thought, no matter how much she denies it, part of her still cares. So I let her out when her friend came to pick her up to go to hers, and we cuddled and I kissed her on the head and for a brief second our hands brushed together. I don't know how to explain this, but it was more like outstretched arms and fingertips brushing together as if you don't want to let them go. Anyway, this was another sign that I knew she genuinely cared.

Moving on to today. I text her the night before asking her what happened in Germany that made her click and that I think she's saying what she feels like she should say rather than what she wants to, it was ignored since it was quite late and we'd been out. So this morning was a bit awkward.

It wasn't until about lunch I plucked up the courage to ask her if there was anyone else and if there was I would walk out of the building and she never had to talk to me again. And she replied saying there was but... she didn't want us to not talk or see each other, which I found odd considering at one point before I moved down she said she never wanted to see me, so I kept my word and walked out and said if I ever meant anything she'd talk to me outside so she did. This is where the first "serious" discussion started, she told me she did like someone else though they aren't "seeing" each other so I asked her "Does someone you've seen for a couple of weeks mean more to you than someone you spent 18 months with?" and to my surprise, she said no. I mean, I get that what I said was well out of order, and I've admitted this and said I've done everything I could to apologise and no matter what I did it's not as if I could take that back and she recognised that wasn't who I really was considering I'd NEVER said anything to hurt her in 18 months. She admitted that it was selfish that she never came to me about what was up instead of texting someone else and we both realised that we made mistakes, and when we said we'd give it another chance I told her she was being unfair in that we were 300 miles apart and she never give us a fair chance to work things out so we spent another 3 hours or so talking...

Now, as I left I text her [we're seeing each other on Thursday and possibly staying on Saturday] saying "And I do need a straight answer who you care more for xxx" because, personally, I think it's almost a rebound relationship because I can't understand how she could "see" someone else but still feel something for me if that relationship meant anything. And she text back saying "ok ill talk to you on thursday x" not once, did she ever admit that she likes this guy more than me and I really don't know what to do about it because if she's not "seeing" him and they've "done" nothing and she still feels more for me [she won't admit it, but you can tell by the body language she does still care - for someone who said "it couldn't work" she was just shy of bursting into tears].

My day in a nutshell, all of this was talked about with her today.
 
Ugh, that's so messed up man. As you said in my thread weeks ago, we're going through practically the same thing. It's heartwrenching and shocking to hear somebody who you've been with for so long, just out of the blue say "This isn't going to work" without a proper reason to follow... and you followed your gut instinct and asked her what it was about, or rather who.

Now I'm no relationship expert or psychologist, but I've seen a lot of shit go down over the last 5 years not just with my own relationship, but with so many others. When there's someone else involved, it sucks. And sometimes, it's almost as if the other person is used to find out the truth. With her texting this guy, but not really seeing him, but putting you two on hold.. it certainly does sound like a rebound, and sometimes people use rebounds to try and get out of something that feels like it's going no where.. but ultimately, it shocks them back into reality and they realize what they've lost and what they're giving up.

She probably realized what was at stake.. You. To give you, and the last 18 months up, only to have to start over and potentially not even have the same chemistry and connection with this new guy... she realized she didn't want that.

It's a shitty game to play and it sucks, but like you said... no relationship has a smooth road, there are bumps and twists around the bend... but you don't want to have to go through that crap again, you know? If something like this happens now, can you be so sure it won't happen another 18 months down the line?

Since you've had a good sit down and talked stuff out is a good step in the right direction, but it sounds like you still have alot more to go, if you have the chance.
 
It sounds to me as if she wants to break it off with you but doesn't want to hurt your feelings. She might agree that what she had with you was special, but at the end of the day this new guy hasn't been given the same period of time the two of you shared together. There's no way she'll say she feels more for him nor the same way, but she could well be more attracted to him for different reasons and may what to experience a different kind of relationship than the one she shared with you.

Ultimately, I think the solution lies with you and whether you want her back or you want to move on (but can't?). It sounds to me as if you're doing a lot of the chasing (with the txts, questions about other males) and that can push a girl away, especially since it screams insecurity (not that you are, just that it gives the impression). It sounds as if the two of you share a strong bond, but she might just not feel the same kind of attraction anymore that you do(?).

Feel free to pull me up if I've got the wrong impression here. I hope - whatever happens between the two of you - that it's for the best. Good luck Ryan. (y)
 
I can kind of relate to this subject, as a similar thing happened with my ex. And after reading your thread it brings it all back, and I really don't know what to say, I don't want to insult or upset you but I will tell you what can happen.

I got my heartbroken twice, by the same guy, and overthinking and wondering "what if" made the pain even worse than it was when he broke it off for good, maybe I could've spared all that pain in the first place when he finished with me the first time.

When someone starts doubting a relationship, most of the time it won't go away, if you and your ex were to reconcile, that doubt will probably still be there, niggling away at her, and maybe you as well. I was really hurt when it happened to me the first time, and I did the same, hoping to get him back, and I did but then I wondered "what if we split again" and I became scared, and it happened anyway, and it hurt twice as much.

Anyway what I'm trying to say is, I don't really know, it's completely your choice, maybe it will work out and your ex will help sort the relationship out, each relationship is different, but if I had that situation again? I would move on, no matter how painful the break up was, as I don't want that pain again.

Maybe you could try and stay in her life though in some way? She seems to have a lot going on, she does seem to care about you and want you in her life, if you were to concentrate on helping her with her problems, and then looking at the relationship between you, it might make a difference.

I can't say for sure, but I hope it really works out for you, I'm really not sure if I helped, sorry :sad:
 
To quote:

Kayleigh ♥ says:
i never said i loved him

This is the sort of stuff that makes me want to bang my head off a wall. At the end of the day I'll give her the ultimatum of either him or me and that means as friends as well, I can't be her friend knowing that she is seeing someone else but still has feelings for me.
 
Ahh, it's like puppy love. :lew:

I think one of the main things to point out here is that you're both still young. Being early in your relationship life, means that some random person may just spring up and become a burden on your love life. When I was your age, I had my first girlfriend, and she cheated on me with a mutual friend of ours. For a long time after that, I never had any faith in a girl that was younger than me. Maturity isn't translated by age, but it is a standard to use as a reference, so that was what I stuck with at the time. That was damn near 10 years ago, and I'm just finding true love now in my life. But the fact that you're still young and with a ton of promise, maybe it's time to look a little further into the future.

I'll be blunt and totally honest, I don't like the situation you're in. It reminds me a lot of my aforementioned relationship that only ended in heartbreak. If she loves you so much and doesn't love him, then why does she so closely associate with him? They're really good friends, even though they haven't known each other for very long? I'm not buying what she's selling. I think she's lying to you, without having to play off her reactions, just by what you've told us.

It's ultimately up to you whether you decide to start seeing her again, but I think that will be a rocky road when all is said and done. As for the remaining friends thing, staying friends with your ex is generally a bad idea, in my experience. You'll always feel uncomfortable when talking to this person, and you'll be sort of awkward and nervous just because you're not sure how you should be. So I think that if you do break it off with her, that cutting all ties is the best thing.

I hope all goes well for you, Ryan. :ryan:
 
This should be "Why some people can't be damn honest and straight to the point?" Thread.

Well Ryan I can related with your situation. There's been this girl I've loved my whole life, but I know we might still be too young. The problem is, I've always faced her asking her what kind of role does she sees in me in the future, whether a friend or a boyfriend or even a husband. She says she doesn't know, and that it might be too soon to even think about that. We've had our ups and downs as friends, but point is, we can't be friends when she acts one way in front of me and completely different when I am not present.

I've heard friends telling me she is completely different when she is outside, talkative and whatnot, but when she talks to me she becomes shy, silent and nervous. So I don't know if I am either intimidating or if she likes me, which is what gets on my nerves because I am someone who values honesty in a relationship, whether it is friendship or something more deep.

So I am stuck believing she doesn't want me yet but doesn't want to let me go, which I consider quite selfish from her part. I told her, (like Ryan) that if she wanted me to go she only needed to say it, and I would completely make all within my power to leave her life. In fact, I have Basic Training+ MOS Training scheduled for next year, and I told her that if she wanted me out of her life, I would pursue the option of staying studying in the United States since I also have family there who gave me the option to stay with them. Only thing preventing me to go is her and her indecision.

Another thing is, several of my "friends" have been badmouthing me behind my back, which they don't know I found out because truth always finds its way. She told her brother about it, said she was upset because of what they said, but when I confronted her and asked her to tell me what they said she says it wasn't a big deal.

I know what they said, and honestly it didn't bother me much, I know they are full of ignorance.

The only thing I ask from her is honesty, and if she is not telling me in order to protect me well then it is kind of working the opposite. Another thing is, I think she wants to play on the "jealous" game by posting stuff she knows I will see (so I am playing the "I haven't seen anything" strategy, like monkey does not hears, does not sees, does not speaks)

So I am in the same situation as Ryan, I can't be friends with someone who can't be honest with me.

Heck, I've even been friends with people who at first told me bluntly they didn't like me, but I told them I wanted to be friends anyway because they had the GUTS to tell it in my face and not behind my back, which is something I really value.
 
This is the sort of stuff that makes me want to bang my head off a wall. At the end of the day I'll give her the ultimatum of either him or me and that means as friends as well, I can't be her friend knowing that she is seeing someone else but still has feelings for me.

That's likely to only end badly for the two of you. She'll undoubtedly still have feelings for you and she probably always will but if a girlfriend did that to me it would sound like emotional blackmail. It might just end up pushing her even further away.

I'd suggest that if you really want her back you back off and make her see how much better she'd be with you. If you feel she's making a mistake, let her. Let her see and feel how much worse the change is (without gloating of course) and she'll end up wanting you back. Getting another love interest and/or showing her little interest will raise her attraction to you.

Then don't take her back.

Works for me anyway. Sometimes you've got to be a cunt for the greater good. The end certainly justifies the means.
 
In honesty, I don't know if I'm strong enough to ditch her altogether. I can't "just" be her friend because there's always going to be a part of me who wants more, yet I told her today we can't see each other and I just couldn't do it because she's the only one down here that can offer me the -right- support I need, yet she's the one person I need to avoid.
 
This should be "Why some people can't be damn honest and straight to the point?" Thread.

Well Ryan I can related with your situation. There's been this girl I've loved my whole life, but I know we might still be too young. The problem is, I've always faced her asking her what kind of role does she sees in me in the future, whether a friend or a boyfriend or even a husband. She says she doesn't know, and that it might be too soon to even think about that. We've had our ups and downs as friends, but point is, we can't be friends when she acts one way in front of me and completely different when I am not present.

I've heard friends telling me she is completely different when she is outside, talkative and whatnot, but when she talks to me she becomes shy, silent and nervous. So I don't know if I am either intimidating or if she likes me, which is what gets on my nerves because I am someone who values honesty in a relationship, whether it is friendship or something more deep.

So I am stuck believing she doesn't want me yet but doesn't want to let me go, which I consider quite selfish from her part. I told her, (like Ryan) that if she wanted me to go she only needed to say it, and I would completely make all within my power to leave her life. In fact, I have Basic Training+ MOS Training scheduled for next year, and I told her that if she wanted me out of her life, I would pursue the option of staying studying in the United States since I also have family there who gave me the option to stay with them. Only thing preventing me to go is her and her indecision.

Another thing is, several of my "friends" have been badmouthing me behind my back, which they don't know I found out because truth always finds its way. She told her brother about it, said she was upset because of what they said, but when I confronted her and asked her to tell me what they said she says it wasn't a big deal.

I know what they said, and honestly it didn't bother me much, I know they are full of ignorance.

The only thing I ask from her is honesty, and if she is not telling me in order to protect me well then it is kind of working the opposite. Another thing is, I think she wants to play on the "jealous" game by posting stuff she knows I will see (so I am playing the "I haven't seen anything" strategy, like monkey does not hears, does not sees, does not speaks)

So I am in the same situation as Ryan, I can't be friends with someone who can't be honest with me.

Heck, I've even been friends with people who at first told me bluntly they didn't like me, but I told them I wanted to be friends anyway because they had the GUTS to tell it in my face and not behind my back, which is something I really value.

And not to take away from your thread Ryan, but isn't it a shame people are getting away with being more evasive these days? Then if you try to press them they have the right to be overly defensive like there is something wrong. I feel it's almost as bad as lying to my face when people can't tell me what's the matter. I know sometimes I need the truth. I won't be be mad. Hell honesty runs me, or else if I know folks are lying, I'll start falling to that nasty habit to.

Though Ryan, since you and I have already discussed this in good amounts. My opinion stands. If you know she's got one foot out the door and in the door, just because of a new toy, I'd say unfortunately some people need ultimatums.

I know it will be hard for you to face, but it's only the beginning of your University, so I'll say this would almost be a fresh start. Sometimes it's better to be alone so others can see what they are missing. I'm not saying start vicariously dating women left and right to try to rouse her curiosity, though I will say if she's ready to move on, and just doesn't want to hurt you, it's time to build back your wall and get over the bridge.

Unfortunately this type of shiznit happens all the time.
 
I just dealt with it by sending her new "toy" a message on facebook containing the chat log I saved the other night from our her and my convo anyway :monster?
 
Ultimately, after a year spent together, this person has become a huge part of your life. So frankly it's quite unreasonable to just 'cut them out'. It's not that easy unless you're an emotionally detached person. And it's also unfair of her to want to not be with you, but still be friends. It's the most difficult thing to just 'be friends' because of all the stuff you went through. Maybe a few years down the line after you've both moved on, sure.. but not right after.

I think you'd be in the right to just give her an ultimatum.

...although what you did just now is highly unethical. I approve. :monster:
 
I've done it with a 2 year relationship, I never said it was easy. I'm saying the only thing I can see is, sometimes you gotta work on yourself. What often times occurs is that folks are ...what's the word... weakened where they rely on the other person a bit more than they should creating a strange codependency. Though the odd thing is, one of the smallest things can occur to make this attachment diminish. You could sneeze a certain way, snore, things that people develop pet peeves over time with.

It's just some people need the newness so that they can see as little imperfections as possible in the smallest amount of time. Hence at Uni the folks feel the need to not have relationships, just date a bit to try out the waters, which I never understood really. I understand the rush and the puppy love at first, and that diminishes over time, but seriously.

I know you can't expect it to be all like.. "detach and let go", but that's not what I'm asking. No matter if you detach or not that person will always be in you. It's very possible later that ya'll will get back together, but for now.. meh. Don't be a casualty, if you get the feeling she's already gone.
 
Lol, it was highly unethical yeah but the way I saw it at the time, she's been messing me around going I like this other guy, don't love him, care for you more etc then today when I met her I told her we can't see each other any more and she went "why can't we be friends" and that was just...IT.

Now she knows how I felt when she messed me around.
 
I'd say unfortunately some people need ultimatums.
I think you'd be in the right to just give her an ultimatum.

I strongly advise against it.

Consider the position you're in Ryan; there's no real substance to your ultimatum. I was in a similar position three years back.

If you've been texting and phoning her regularly about getting back together, is she really supposed to believe you're going to walk away now?

Let's face it, even if you could walk away, does she believe you could? Because that's really what matters and I'd wager she thinks (either consciously or subconsciously) you're hooked and she won't lose you based on all the effort you've put into contacting her, being there for her (emotionally), etc. To provide an ultimatum one has to have the power. You don't in this case because if you go, she's free to fall into the arms of this new guy and if you stick around, your ultimatum has fallen flat on it's face.

Ignore the ultimatum, if the solution really was as simple as your past together there wouldn't be this other guy.

I'd advise you just distance yourself from her. Don't accomodate her questions, don't come to her with your problems, be too busy for her, etc.

If you do those things you are essentially jumping through hoops for her - like a chump so to speak, which would nullify your ultimatum to her.

Soon she'll stop thinking of you as a potential friend and begin to miss the intimacy you shared as a couple.

Remember that pragmatism wins over sentiment and nice guys most certainly finish last. Some of us learn the hard way.
 
:hmmm: The man makes a very good point, and I hadn't taken that into account. Despite the fact that you laid it all in front for us, I forgot about some of those things, and Harls right about the ultimatum lacking substance, given your contact recently.

He's right. Show that you've begun to move on without her (even if you have to fake it). Stop replying to texts so soon (or at all), screen her calls every now and again, don't hang out every single chance you have... As soon as she realizes that she's beginning to lose you, she'll start to want you all the more.

Or... she may just realize that you've already started to move on, and so now does she. Hard to say...
 
Nicely done (y)

Just make sure you keep her there though, if you keep her at arms length to long she might just end up with this new geezer anyway =/
 
I don't even think I want her back anymore. I've given her the chance to talk and every time she does she gives me mixed messages and when I spoke to her last night I told her I gave her everything and she said it's more than what she wanted.

I don't want someone like that in my life tbqh. :dave:
 
I don't even think I want her back anymore. I've given her the chance to talk and every time she does she gives me mixed messages and when I spoke to her last night I told her I gave her everything and she said it's more than what she wanted.

I don't want someone like that in my life tbqh. :dave:

In fairness to her she was probably being evasive in her language because she didn't want to hurt you.

From what I've understood she just wasn't attracted to you anymore but didn't want to hurt you, especially since you made it obvious you still wanted something between the two of you. Yeah she should've been straight with you but in all honesty can you blame her for being that way?

What if the roles were reversed and you had another girl, would you really be as straight as you would've liked her to be to you?
 
Back
Top