this is an interesting thread. i'll give my bit as well.
even if it's two blocks away, it is in new york city, and the WTC event wasn't limited to just ground zero, it caused major collateral damage and traumatized just about everyone who got engulfed in the smoke clouds, and it has a permanent place in the memory of anyone who heard it on the news that morning. it is hardly insignificant.
the other kicker is that this is a mosque, not exactly a center devoted to bridging the misunderstandings and healing the misconceptions about islam. it is a mosque, built for muslims to practice islam. how would this mosque go about fulfilling its declaration of improving relations with americans, when it is located near a place that continues to serve as a powerful reminder of the religion's fanatics? it will be vandalized, spit upon, and ridiculed. say what you might, but you can't deny that ground zero is a large thorn in islam's side, and an islamic complex, no matter how expensive, no matter how cleanly, no matter how kind, can't hope to erase it. the demonstration shows that the residents of new york have not forgotten 9/11. this isn't to say building it is wrong; it is a bad idea, however, in my humble opinion.
even if it's two blocks away, it is in new york city, and the WTC event wasn't limited to just ground zero, it caused major collateral damage and traumatized just about everyone who got engulfed in the smoke clouds, and it has a permanent place in the memory of anyone who heard it on the news that morning. it is hardly insignificant.
the other kicker is that this is a mosque, not exactly a center devoted to bridging the misunderstandings and healing the misconceptions about islam. it is a mosque, built for muslims to practice islam. how would this mosque go about fulfilling its declaration of improving relations with americans, when it is located near a place that continues to serve as a powerful reminder of the religion's fanatics? it will be vandalized, spit upon, and ridiculed. say what you might, but you can't deny that ground zero is a large thorn in islam's side, and an islamic complex, no matter how expensive, no matter how cleanly, no matter how kind, can't hope to erase it. the demonstration shows that the residents of new york have not forgotten 9/11. this isn't to say building it is wrong; it is a bad idea, however, in my humble opinion.
Last edited: