SOTW 59 Voting.

[Six]

Theme: Final Fantasy Characters.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

* Entrants are not allowed to vote for their own entries.
* Voting ends in 7 days.
* Posting feedback along with casting a vote is highly appreciated.

 

[Thief of Hearts Joker]

lol I had to vote for the Tonberry, I like the drawn style of the whole piece and the croc dundee line just sealed the deal for me XD

 

[greenyxi]

I also went for number 3. I love the character, design and tagline.
...I keep wanting to say "that's a spoon" when I look it at

The others are all good in their own ways though. Like number 2; it's simple but really clean and stuff

 

[Raiiyokuu]

I'll have to agree with the others.

I'm voting #3 .

1. Too bright, and a bit too sharp around the edges.

2. This would be my second vote.

4. Everything comes together, but the picture's dark.

5 and 6, they both need better blending, but good effort.

 

[The Witch]

1GMV

it's outstanding. I like the size, I like the color, I like the placement of the focus and text as well. It's just very nice. Good job. The only one that comes close to #1 is #4 . It's got it all. In fact, I would have voted for it but I don't really like that colored box behind the text. It kinda throws me off. Both of these sigs are amazing though. bravo

 

[Master Cat]

No. 2 GMV

I was originally going to vote for No. 3, but I had a feeling that this great piece would fall through the cracks, so-to-speak. It may be on the bright side, but I think the composition is great, the text is fitting, and I like the sketchy/blurred look thrown in there. I also like how the background doesn't take over the subject of the signature, that way Hope is still the main feature. I think some backgrounds tend to take on a life of their own and become too distracting, so this signature has a nice balance imo.

No. 1 - I think this signature is good and it would make a great avatar/sig set, but it seemed a little too safe to me? Nice background and Sephy artwork, but it just didn't stand out too much for me. Also, the text and color scheme are good, but I do wish it were a bit bigger. It's a little on the traditional signature skinny size, lol.

No. 3 - I really liked this piece and thought it was the most creative of them all. I like the artwork and I think it's cool how it has a dual function as the forefront subject and the background, yet it doesn't appear to be too overwhelming. The border is a nice touch and the text is quite funny. Idk, I felt like this sig was getting so much attention and sure to win anyhow, so I voted for No. 2, but apparently this entry is tied with No. 4. Sorry about that! xD

No. 4 - I like the composition of the image and the text, but I think the purple tones are a bit of an overkill. I think it would have been nice if there was more of a contrast between the background and the Caius image, 'cause they blend in a bit too much color-wise (unless that was the artist's intention, then it's completely fine, lol). Also, I wish I could read the really small printed text, but I know there are a few signatures like that, so I guess it's there for the look more than for reading, lol...

No. 5 - I think this piece has great potential, but I'd have to say that I wasn't too swayed by the Yuna artwork chosen, and I also think that the background could've been a bit more sophisticated? It doesn't really fit the image used, but it's on the right track! I think it would've been great to see a different Yuna artwork or maybe an original CG render of Yuna thrown in there.

No. 6 - The same with this one - I feel like the image and the background don't really mesh well together, and it's a little too random (unless that place in the background is actually from FFXIII, but I don't recognize it, lol). The artist used a pretty cool image of Lightning and the reddish color scheme is nice, but maybe a little too much on the red hue (similar to how I feel about the Caius one).

There's my 2 cents. xD;

 

[Galadín]

The two I am having the most difficulty deciding over is #3 and #4. Both pieces are incredible.

#3:

This piece is quite different and stands out due to its innovative flare and originality. There is a lot to like about this artwork. Its simplicity is endearing and the design is very eye catching. It is one of those kind of things that could really start a cult! The only criticism I would have for the entry, is that the boarder on the left hand side seems to try a bit too hard- if you catch my drift. I just think it looks excessively sketchy looking compared to the right hand boarder.

In the end though, the signature full deserves the attention it has been getting.

#4:

This signature is simply stunning. I absolutely love the effects and details incorporated into it. I think the dark tomes really set off the mood and adds depth and character to the piece. The highlights make it all come together and only enhance the slight mystic quality this signature seems to have. I also particularly like the way the hair was done!
About the only thing that I would say in anyways negative about this entry is in regards to the main text. I'm not overly fond of the glowing blue outline. Although I completely understand the necessity for it, I would still say that perhaps choosing to select a light colour text for this part may have helped better if legibility was a problem. Alternatively, toning down the outline a bit and decreasing the opacity of it might have also helped ease the overly bright appearance it gives.

Well, now it is decision time For the life of me I still cannot make up my mind....
*******************************************

After looking at them again I would have to say that I would vote for #4. The details are just spot on!

 

[Tucker]

Had to vote 4; it is absolutely stunning! The colors and text all go together perfectly. It draws you in and makes you want to just stare at it 0_0 Very nice job!

I also liked number 2

 

[The Welsh Paddy]

Deku Sprout Hayabusa I'm Blue Jill Valentine Yu Narukami

And even Chanteru and Galadín

You all made me feel like a winner. (Just wanted to get that in before this thread is closed! )

 

[Six]

A huge thanks to all the entrants & voters that gave this thread a few minutes of their time. Things like these really inspire and give the graphic section that little boost it needs again. Thank you, and I can't wait to see how the next voting works out!

1. Galadín
2. C i d
3. The Welsh Paddy
4. Six (winning entry)
5. JeriKane1998
6. Yu Narukami

All of you entrants can expect a little bonus donation this time around for making this SOTW voting thread worth it.

BUT PLEASE --- do not send me a thank you message like the system asks you!
I'll get bombed with PMs.

​