SOTW 41 Voting Thread

Which signature is best?


  • Total voters
    24
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
The sig being too big is not a justified reason for not voting for it. On some forums the average size of a tag is double of what it is here. So not cool.:neomon:
Of course it is. Large tags don't appeal to me. Even if the limit is so large, it'd take something truly outstanding for me to use it.
 
The sig being too big is not a justified reason for not voting for it. On some forums the average size of a tag is double of what it is here. So not cool.:neomon:

In all fairness to Pools, he did jusitfy why he picked another one instead. It might just be that, big to him might not be big to someone else, there may not be many people who think it's big but on the other hand there will be people who do...and hell, its a more of a valid reason then "I liked the character" :neomon:

---
Gah, he beat me to it -__- :ninja:
 
Last edited:
Yo Random, you could have tried a different background effect :P same as last week man :P

1. Don't like it, you could have put some more effort..

2. The BG and the text don't fit with the stock IMO, also too bright, maybe next time try a different font and lower the lighting..

3. I like it, nice placement of the stock and good use of font and text...

4. Nice, but not quite finished in my eyes, still needs somethin

5. Nice try, but there's too much goin on, and I don't like the font. You should focus on Joilie more, kind of make her stand out more...

6. Nice placement of stock again, simple and clean, not much to say...

7. Great, allround, not notes or nothing...

Voting for #3 just cause RP used pretty much the same BG and effects as last week.
 
Yo Random, you could have tried a different background effect :P same as last week man :P

1. Don't like it, you could have put some more effort..

2. The BG and the text don't fit with the stock IMO, also too bright, maybe next time try a different font and lower the lighting..

3. I like it, nice placement of the stock and good use of font and text...

4. Nice, but not quite finished in my eyes, still needs somethin

5. Nice try, but there's too much goin on, and I don't like the font. You should focus on Joilie more, kind of make her stand out more...

6. Nice placement of stock again, simple and clean, not much to say...

7. Great, allround, not notes or nothing...

Voting for #3 just cause RP used pretty much the same BG and effects as last week.

Which one's RP's???
 
The sig being too big is not a justified reason for not voting for it. On some forums the average size of a tag is double of what it is here. So not cool.:neomon:

I wouldn't really say double unless we're talking about width. tags get pretty wide on some of the other boards I've been on. :wacky:

I see #2 fine.

that's good. :neomon:

In all fairness to Pools, he did jusitfy why he picked another one instead. It might just be that, big to him might not be big to someone else, there may not be many people who think it's big but on the other hand there will be people who do...and hell, its a more of a valid reason then "I liked the character" :neomon:

you really only need to describe why you like the one you voted for. You don't have to elaborate on the lesser one that catches your eye. ;p

1. Don't like it, you could have put some more effort..

the intention was to put in less effort and work with a different style. Kind of like going back to square one, but with all your past knowledge, and delving into something different. :neomon:

Voting for #3 just cause RP used pretty much the same BG and effects as last week.

bzzzzzzzzzt.

wrong.

:neomon:

Which one's RP's???

guess. :wacky:
 
My vote goes to 4, I like the color scheme and Beckinsale is just fucking hawt :wacky:

Three is really just as good, I love the colors.....but it's not Beckinsale. And the first one is just... *facepalm*
 
My vote goes to 4, I like the color scheme and Beckinsale is just fucking hawt :wacky:

Three is really just as good, I love the colors.....but it's not Beckinsale. And the first one is just... *facepalm*

I know this is off topic, but when does Beckinsale doesn't look HAWT? She is always hawt, at least, to me :wacky:

And on a side note, I started to analyze the Angelina Jolie siggy, and here's what I think:
-Random C4D usage (somewhat like going crazy with C4Ds), doesn't go accordingly with the stock used.
-The size, I don't like it. Not fond of big sigs, sorry.
-The text looks somehow awkward.
-The colors somehow is a no-no.
-For the second time, background and stock don't seem to fit.
-The C4D chosen is not actually, the best around. The same sig, or a new one, should be made without that C4D.


Sorry for being harsh, but that's what I see. Light is always hard when she criticizes my work (for that I am grateful for she had helped me to become better). I always prefer the bitter truth than a sweat lie. I know that if she thinks my avatar sucks (and it does right now :P) she won't hesitate to tell me, and I always expect that to happen:neomon:

Thanks again Light!
 
Sorry for being harsh, but that's what I see. Light is always hard when she criticizes my work (for that I am grateful for she had helped me to become better). I always prefer the bitter truth than a sweat lie. I know that if she thinks my avatar sucks (and it does right now :P) she won't hesitate to tell me, and I always expect that to happen:neomon:

Thanks again Light!

Lol you make me really want to rip into all the sigs now (including my own), but I will resist the temptaion :P

Beckinsale is one of my favourite actresses. She is smoking hot and can do some serious acting as well. Plus she's British (yay) and hasn't turned into the typical LA garbage since moving there.
 
It's between #4 and #3 for me. I'm gonna go with with #3. I like the size and color scheme better.
 
I know this is off topic, but when does Beckinsale doesn't look HAWT? She is always hawt, at least, to me :wacky:

Very good point. Beckinsale is delicious cake.

And on a side note, I started to analyze the Angelina Jolie siggy, and here's what I think:
-Random C4D usage (somewhat like going crazy with C4Ds), doesn't go accordingly with the stock used.
-The size, I don't like it. Not fond of big sigs, sorry.
-The text looks somehow awkward.
-The colors somehow is a no-no.
-For the second time, background and stock don't seem to fit.
-The C4D chosen is not actually, the best around. The same sig, or a new one, should be made without that C4D.
Or to sum that all up: the C4D and colors are too busy, plus they blend with Jolie's hair and dress and make her hard to distinguish from the background. Hue changing mighta fixed that, I dunno.

And now that you mention C4Ds....I noticed I have that same one in your L sig, I just haven't found a way to use it yet. Hurray for the concept series on DA :wacky:
 
the intention was to put in less effort and work with a different style. Kind of like going back to square one, but with all your past knowledge, and delving into something different.

I know!!! But it didn't work :D :P IMO

bzzzzzzzzzt.

wrong.

So someone else used the same BG and effects as he did last week??? That makes want to vote for it even less :P :P
 
:nudge:Mugen, I think your looking at the wrong sig. I only made mine in a few minutes on a different computer so it definitely doesn't have the same effects.
 
Ok, got that from Derek's

bzzzzzzzzzt.

wrong.

:D Then like is said, someone pretty much copied your style from last week IMO. Not saying it's bad or anythin, just that I noticed it :P
 
I picked #7 because it has good graphics it shows alot of action, and colors. It popped out to me and I think it was the best one out of them all.
 
Congratulations, Eidolon. You've won sotw 41. :neomon:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top