SOTW 35 Voting thread

Which signature do you like most?

  • Total voters
    17
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

L

Iller than Radiation
Veteran
Joined
Jan 15, 2007
Messages
4,103
Age
35
Gil
0
FFXIV
Ellen Stone
FFXIV Server
Adamantoise
Please read the updated rules in the SOTW Results & Discussion thread before voting.


1
SoTW-1.png


2
SOTW35WIP.png


3
dereksig3.png


4
CrisisCore.jpg


5
Aerithsiggy.png


6
Crisis-Core.jpg
 
Sir Balthier said:
2!

Put some text in there mind.
Click to expand...

Did you even read what I said in my first post? :wacky:

Updated SOTW Rules said:
1.) Do not vote for your own entry. You will be immediately disqualified if you do so.

2.) Do not submit the same sig/tag in more than one SOTW. That's just silly, and will get you disqualified.

3.) Do not submit and old tag. I don't mean one you made a week ago, (that I can let slide), but I mean one that's been sitting on your hard drive for months that you just never did anything with.

4.) All entries regardless of the theme, must fit the forum sig limits which is 500x200.

5.) All votes must have a post to match, or they will be discarded.

6.) You must elaborate on what you like about the signature that you are voting for. Voting for a signature because it has a character you like in it just as a reason all by itself is a perfect example of how to get your vote invalidated. Votes without proper elaboration of what strikes your fancy about the graphic will be discarded as well. This does not mean that you have to write a paragraph critique. Appreciate the overall signature you're voting for, not just the character in it.
Click to expand...
 
Sir Balthier, please reframe from spam. I'll allow Zack to handle this as its his thread and his section.

And my response was "Shit, they're good!" lol. Man, this is tough as all are damn amazing. So difficult ...

Hmm, 1, 2 and 3 are my favs. This is hard. Im saying ... 3! As I love the image, the colour, text and lighting are all great.

Sexcellent jobs here people, be proud!
 
...

I chose 1, because it really is a different design, it's very vibrant, plus there's all sorts of different shapes making it up which make it the all more unique.
 
This is pretty tough.

I like how 1's text was placed almost like a camouflage lighting. The background is pretty awesome, but there's something missing, it seems. =/ I'm not exactly sure what...but I would have voted for 1 if I had felt that "completeness" to the whole signature. It's still a unique design though, so thumbs up for that.

So I'm gonna have to go with 3. It's pretty smooth and clean looking...not too many special-effects going on, but it really caught my attention, nonetheless. The lighting on top really did it for me as it just made the whole signature complete in a way.
 
Sir Balthier said:
You wish me to elaborate in the discussion/results thread yes?
Click to expand...

No... I mean for you to elaborate on what you like about the signature you're voting for in this thread.

For example.... 'The colors go well with the image' or 'I really like the effect used on it that looks like so and so', and etc. Say what you like about the signature is all. :neomon:
 
I went for 2, it stood out to me the most.. I like the colours and the swirly light in it. The only thing I would add would be some text maybe, but other than that I think it's the best. Number 3 came close though, as I felt the other ones had a little too much going on in them.
 
Pistol said:
It's between 1 & 2, but I voted for 1! Great job, though.
Click to expand...

:ffs:

Zack said:
Please read the updated rules in the SOTW Results & Discussion thread before voting.
Click to expand...

UPDATED SOTW RULES said:
1.) Do not vote for your own entry. You will be immediately disqualified if you do so.

2.) Do not submit the same sig/tag in more than one SOTW. That's just silly, and will get you disqualified.

3.) Do not submit and old tag. I don't mean one you made a week ago, (that I can let slide), but I mean one that's been sitting on your hard drive for months that you just never did anything with.

4.) All entries regardless of the theme, must fit the forum sig limits which is 500x200.

5.) All votes must have a post to match, or they will be discarded.

6.) You must elaborate on what you like about the signature that you are voting for. Voting for a signature because it has a character you like in it just as a reason all by itself is a perfect example of how to get your vote invalidated. Votes without proper elaboration of what strikes your fancy about the graphic will be discarded as well. This does not mean that you have to write a paragraph critique. Appreciate the overall signature you're voting for, not just the character in it.
Click to expand...
 
Zack said:
Please read the updated rules in the SOTW Results & Discussion thread before voting.


1
SoTW-1.png


2
SOTW35WIP.png



4
CrisisCore.jpg
Click to expand...

I had a hard time debating with myself to which signature would be adequate to give my vote, but in the end I decided that Entry # 4 gets my vote. My reasons since I measured the difficulty that it probably took to made it. Second, the colors and light effects used around the characters. Third the colors, I just loved the colors, specially the ones used to illuminate the character in the center of the signature.

Number 1 was cool, and the light used on the text killed it. I can barely read what it says.

Number 2 was also cool, but somehow 4 was better.
 
i voted for 1, wow thats amazing, great focal and it flows like nothing i've ever seen in me life and the text is great too :D nice work :D
 
I had a tough time between #2 and #3 as they were both very well done. I ended up choosing #3. The coloring was well executed, c4ds gave off a nice effect, and the lighting was done nicely. Text is always hard to pull of but it was pretty good.
 
3-4-6 for me

4 would get my vote if the Shinra logo was distorted to match the BG
Still I like how natural the lighting looks. The beyond characters face also should have some red reflection to match the stage

It's hard to decide between three and six. Both are well done. Nice blending, Nice lighting.

After about five minutes, I choose No# six.
 
Last edited:
I'm going for #3, as Mitsuki has rightly pointed out, there are "not too many special effects going on" which is what makes it stand out from the rest. The colour choice and C4D were obviously chose with precision and have been blended with the Zack image very well and the lightning is fab too!...and the text just wraps up a great sig.
Nevertheless, credit to everyone who entered, they are all great sigs and keep up the great work everyone. :wink:
 
2, 3 and 4 appealed to me the most here but I'm going to vote for 3. 2 is a little too big for my tastes and the sig doesn't fit together as well as 3 which keeps it simple but has enough in there to still make it stand out. 4 while is looks nice is just spoiled by having way too much in there which is a shame.
 
I vote for number 3, it's simple, but it's effective, and I thought it looked the best out of all the ones there.
 
To those of you who have read the updated rules that I've posted at least twice in this thread, and complied with them: Thank you.

To those of you who have not read the updated rules and failed to comply with them: Your votes have been invalidated towards the individual's signature you voted for. Please remember to post which entry you voted for and to elaborate on what you like about the signature in the future.

Please read the rules before voting in the next thread.

Total

1) 2 votes
2) 1 Votes
3) 6 Votes
4) 1 Votes
5) 0 Votes
6) 1 Votes

Our winner is Matrix! :neomon:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top