Rate The Sig And Avatar Above You V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Avi: 7/10
I love the colours and text, but I don't see the point of just having the username in it, seeing as it's just over the avi anyway, could do with some more text maybe.

Sig: 9/10
Loving the Pink Sig, the colours are funky, and it kind of clashes which makes it stand out.
 
Icon: 9
I give it that because it's not plain(like most icons usually are) It's a little blurry but not too bad. All in all, I think it's good. The effect is really nice too :3

Banner: 9
It's a good size and it's much clearer than the icon. The writing kind of throws me off...just a bit. But not too much. The effect(not sure what to call it)is a nice touch, but I feel it needs something more. You picked a very good spot to put the words, it flows very easily.

Other than that, I wish you would have matched your icon to your banner, it would have been really nice. But they both look really great either way! So good job!
 
Avatar: 8
It's really nice, but there's always room for improvement. I do not know what it's about, but it looks neat. :)

Sig: 8.5
It's just an enlarged version of your avatar, so the score barely changes on this one. Still neat, though.

Overall, I think what you have is a nice piece of work. Is it yours, or did you get it from somewhere? it's from you, good job. If you just found it, nice find, too. :)
 
Last edited:
Its not mine. It's Amano's artwork for FFVII of Cloud and Aerith.

Icon: 7
Wayy to small. Not much is on it, but the picture is cool.

Banner: 8
I like the size and I like the purple color. The stock is cool too. Even the words are nice, but they look almost blocky on the edges. The border is cool, but IMO it could do without the fuzzy glow.

Other than that, good job! C;
 
Set: 9/10 I like the drawing of Cloud and Aerith. They look great, although I hate these oldish looking drawings. The text added looks great, although it is hard to read. Looks great as a sig, but as an avatar, it's too plain and the reduced size takes away it's key features.
 
Set: 9
I like the dark tone of it. The render is placed very nicely too. The font isn't as kick ass-looking as the rest of the banner is, but it's still cool.

Link Banner: 10
I love the choice of that picture of Link. It's perfect. I really like how that green fog is like wrapping around him, it makes Link look 3D almost. The choice of font throws me off just a tad. But the color is wonderful.

Red bar: 10
Very nice color choice. I can't make those so I always like them. C:
 
Set: 6
- While I like both pics they kinda give off a bland feeling. Perhapse you could mix in some color to make it stand out more...I think that one particular pic works better as a sig than an Avi.
 
Icon: 8
Death note? Yea, well, I give it a 8 because it's just a picture. There's not much going on, just her.

Banner: 6
It could use a border of some kind... The render used is nice. I like the combination of the two pics. but the red background takes the spotlight away from Serah, though. Instead of focusing on her, all I see is that red background with the blue-swirl-thing. Maybe instead of using two completely different colors, you could match them to the render you're using. Still, it's nice.
 
An interesting stock choice. It does look a bit flat though.
Although the colours look a little dull, they still work. I particularly like the reds around the text and towards the the top left.
I think the text works very well and the white border finishes it off nicely.

7/10 for both the avatar and signature.
 
Last edited:
I give you a 9 for the icon. I sure like the background and the eyes just get to me.

As for the sig, sorry to disappoint but I never did like Megan Fox. Still, it's a nice pic, so I'll give you an 8 for it.

Your overall score would be 8.5, I believe.
 
Set: 8.5

The avatar has a nice background and comes out nicely, just looks very blurry to me.

The signature is great, just looks kind of plain and is dark in the wrong place. The background doesn't look right and the render looks slightly blurry. The font pulls everything together and saves the piece, though.
 
Avatar: 8.5 Although it is just a part of your first sig, it looks like it could have been designed as a seperate avatar anyway.

Sig 1: 9.5 I like the fact that the character blends well with the background and that nothing in the sig takes attention away from the main focal points, even with the bright streak of light in the bottom left.

Sig 2: 9.5 Very similar to the one above, except that in this one the zoomed in part of the image behind has been lined up perfectly to keep the cloak blended with the background without taking attention away with a much brighter colour.

Also you can do text. Which I can't. I like it. It's cool. Tell me how you do it.
 
Avatar: 8 I like the colors and the character, but it seems kind of plain to me, it needs something, maybe it should be brightened?

Signature: 8 also, its good but I feel like, again, something is missing, maybe some text would lighten it up.
 
Icon: 9
At first sight, I liked it. I really don't know what to say, but I like the character.

Sig: 9
It's the same as your avatar, but the only reason the score is lower is just because of that: they're the same.
 
Last edited:
Leon_L said:
It's the same as your avatar, but the only reason the score is lower is just because of that: they're the same.
Click to expand...

It's called a set :monster:

Avatar: 8.5

It has nice effects and looks great. It's vibrant, but looks slightly blurry and hurts the eyes. More could have been done to it. It's great for an avatar, though

Sig 7.5

The signature is great, just looks kind of plain and is dark in the wrong place. The background doesn't look right and the render looks slightly blurry. The font pulls everything together and saves the piece, though.
 
In that case, consider it changed. :)

Icon: 9.5
7.5 points because I'm sort of an Ike fan, plus 2 more because the color suits him well.

Sig: 9.5
Reasons same as above, for both sigs. Also because it's a set. :)
 
I'll give you a solid 6 for the Avi because it's just a simple pic.

The sig gets a definite 9. I love the background of Zach, which really pulls me in. But one thing about that though- I wish maybe another color could have been used in it perhapse?
 
10/10. Beautifully done.
Now, I just need to find a person to make me a Pit set...
 
Hmm...Icarus, you don't have much to work with, here. But I'll give it a shot...:gasp:

Avy is about a 5/10, mainly since it's just a tiny image of...something. (crossbow?)

Sig gets a 6, since it's a jumble of text and little pet images. Though that quote of Julius is just simply epic. :jess:
 
Ohhhh! Avy and siggy set get a combined 9/10! The colors work great for both though I am not sure if I like the way the colors of the Avi is more bold than the siggy one...

Second siggy gets a 7/10. I love the quote itself in this one. The background however makes the text a little hard to read, but then again its color scheme gives you no other choice...:hmmm:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top