The man in the slums

Is the man in the Pipe, Zack, or not?

  • Yes, I think it's Zack

    Votes: 16 20.3%
  • No, I do not think it's Zack

    Votes: 63 79.7%

  • Total voters
    79
I just think that the dude is another experiment. I don't think that he is Zack at all.
 
Truth be told.
So you're saying that while Cloud was in la la land, Hojo snuck up and took Zack? lol.

I mean really, would he have a reason not to? But it doesn't really match up. So I'm going to vote no.
 
Cloud may have been totally out of it when Zack was shot to death but i would think that when became more aware of things that he would bury Zack for many reason, least of all respect. I mean they were pretty close.

Cloud was also pretty out of it when Sephiroth went crazy, but he still managed to carry Tifa down and place her against one of the vats of Mako and he also still managed to attack Sephiroth and throw him into the Lifestream. Who's to say what really happened, but if I'm not mistaken it does say that Zack was buried right where he was shot to death. I agree with Madison on this 100%.

The man in the slums is NOT Zack. Whoever thought of him being Zack is delusional.
 
For arguments sake, I shall argue FOR the man being Zack.

I believe we are told by the Doctor in Mideel that Cloud would eventually die after too much Mako poinsoning, correct? Possibly, the man in the slums actually did die between the two-year interval of VII and AC?

I'm gonna have to say it isn't Zack. And as for your theory on Mako poisining Riku, I would like to ask how he would have aquired this poisining
if the last time we saw him, he received MULTIPLE shots from a gun at extremely close range. If the shots didn't kill him on the spot, how would he have been able find a Mako/LIfestream well to be poisened. And if that was so, I'm pretty sure that the combination of bullets, and the overdosing amount of Mako in his system, would have killed him long before you would have seen him in that pipe.
 
Didn't square just about sum this up at the end of advent children when you see zack and aeris together?


DEAD.
 
The man in the slums is another Sephiroth Clone, just like tho's men in Black Caps you see later on. The reason he isn't in the slums when you go back to Midgar in Disc 3 is because he's obviously taken part in the 'Reunion'. Its conformed that he is a Sephiroth Clone because of his numbered tattoo he bares that Aeris points out if you visit him prior to going to her house for the first time.
 
I voted Yes,I think it's Zack...my reason:-

The man in the pipe has a #2 SOLDIER tattoo on his hand what does that explain

Only Sephiroth and Zack was in 1st class

EXPLAIN THIS :P :P
 
I voted Yes,I think it's Zack...my reason:-

The man in the pipe has a #2 SOLDIER tattoo on his hand what does that explain

Only Sephiroth and Zack was in 1st class

EXPLAIN THIS :P :P
Makes no sense, but I'll try....

The tattoos arn't for SOLDIER's, they are for Hojo's experiments. Zack never got a tattoo because he was a failed experiment (later mistaken as Cloud). Its not Zack. Zack is dead, deseaced, seized to be, no more, an ex-living being, he is DEAD!

What does 1st Class SOLDIER got to do with it? and no, they arn't the only 1st Class SOLDIER's, just the only one mentioned as far as I know in the game. Angeal in CC is also 1st Class.
 
is there any proof that zack didnt have a tatoo ! just cos cloud didnt doesnt mean that zack wouldnt ! my theory ...... zack was shot repeatedly ......cloud leaves...... some1 finds zack...... takes him back 2 midgar...... he has no memory just as cloud did not in mideel .... he is just blank ...... cloud + Tifa didnt recognise him cos he didnt react 2 sein them (cos of memory loss) ...... he obviously dies b4 AC due to the poisoning that he couldnt cure as he had no memory !!! i say yes !!!!!
 
icloud + Tifa didnt recognise him cos he didnt react 2 sein them (cos of memory loss) ......

Nice theory....but it has one simple flaw - Aerith was with cloud when they were first in the slums - not Tifa - and Aerith would have remembered Zack for sure - so NO he isnt the man in the slums.
 
The man in the slums is a sephy clone as im sure a lot of you know he has one of the number tattoo on his arms and when zack was being experimented on by hojo he was a failre just like cloud so neither one of them recieved tattoos zack wasnt effected by make poisoning as you can tell he is completely healthy is the flashback scene in nibelheim mansion also aerith would have reacognised him unless she got a sudden bout of amnisia i mean come on who doesnt remember tehere first love yu can also see his hair its not spiky as zack infact its flat also its brown and zack had black hair i rest my case your honour lol
 
sos thats my mistake ! i meant aerith ! i was just getting into my theory an typin quick wiv out thinkin !
 
okay ! you may be right ! u seem 2 like showing me up alredy ! an i havent seen the man in the slums for a little wile so i 4get exactly wot he looks like ! i just luv 2 go against the majority ! bit of a rebel maybe haha !
 
Ive never really thought about it. I dont think it is Zack though, I believed Zack to have been dead already.
 
Back
Top