SOTW 30 Voting Thread

SOTW 30

  • 1

    Votes: 15 62.5%
  • 2

    Votes: 3 12.5%
  • 3

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 4

    Votes: 6 25.0%

  • Total voters
    24
  • Poll closed .

Daenerys

The Last Dragon
Veteran
Joined
Nov 26, 2006
Messages
11,178
Age
33
Location
Suburban hell.
Gil
1
The theme this week was couples, to tie in with Valentines day, and I recieved 4 entries ^_^

1)

SOTW301.png


2)

SOTW303.png


3)

SOTW304.png


4)

SOTW305.png
 
I'm voting one, with the risk of you killing me, Mark. :P

I like the blending effects and the contrast of the light and dark. That usually buys me. 8D
 
Wow it's pretty much Cloti vs. Cleris. :O And people are pretty much going to vote for which couple they think is cannon in FFVII and not, you know, which sig is actually better.

Where are the other FF couples :'(

I'll be different and vote #4 :P
 
#4 looks great. I like the blending and the overall sig. Its also different then the others so, it gets my vote.
 
Wow it's pretty much Cloti vs. Cleris. :O And people are pretty much going to vote for which couple they think is cannon in FFVII and not, you know, which sig is actually better.

Where are the other FF couples :'(

I'll be different and vote #4 :P
I was supposed to enter up until about half an hour ago, when I realised that I really don't have any kind of talent on Photoshop. xD I'd intended to make a Gabranth x Drace sig, but that went down the shitter.

It's a close call between #1 and #2 for me and I'm going for #1, purely because of the colour contrast, which is nothing short of an expert's work.
 
I'm not sure why but the affects used in the 2nd one really struck me. I felt 3 was too bland and plain and while I like the simplicity of 4, the foggy haze over it is just a bit much, somewhat distorting the image from truly being seen clearly. It was sort of a toss up between 1 and 2 actually because I love the affects used in the first one as well, but the dark side of the sig and the rose and text threw me off. I don't really feel it meshed well or corresponded with the rest of the sig, so I'll go with 2.
 
I like #4. While I think it should be an Ash/Misty one, I REALLY like how they illustrated Ash.
 
I voted for number one, I felt it had the best combination of theme and talent. Number two and four were both good, but four lacked theme- the characters seemed too far apart. Number four wasn't quite as good graphics-wise as number one was.
Number three wasn't bad (Much better than I could do) but was too simple with too much negative space (if you're a visual artist you know what that is).
 
I'm not the biggest Cloti fan, but I have to acknowledge how well sig number one was made, well done whoever made it!

However, I'm voting for number 4, it's just so different from the others, and small and cute xD
 
i think one was the bast as not only does it look good but cloud and Tifa are my favorite FF couple of all time
 
I was supposed to enter this as well, but I only had like 30 minutes to make one sig and I felt too lazy to make one XD.

Anyhow, I voted for #2, because of the effects the person used. Though it needs more color cause I find it a bit ..too pink....
 
1 and 4 are amazing. But Id have to go for 4 cause I like the lighting used, the colours are good and the image is fantastic! Nice job everyone!
 
I really like the effects of the first one, especially the colors and stuff around Valentine. (though it looks like it has to L's instead of one...)

It's hard to choose between all of them though, because fourth is cute, the second is cool, and the third is cute.

The only thing I don't like about the third one is the fact I've seen that Aerith picture waaaay to much. XD
 
Yum.

#1 - I'm voting for this one. Although there isn't an outstanding amount of chemistry between the two characters, your eyes go directly to them and you can feel the relations between them. Both seem very independent as Cloud casts his gaze outward and Tifa seems concentrated on her glove, and the bubbles and waves are very well done. The rays that float on the 'Vallentine' text almost seems to make it glow, and speaking of which the rose and sparkles are very well done, if they were by hand. I would've appreciated a bit more grid patterns in the upper-right hand corner, but the sheer fact that it's already there allows every pixel of this signature to be interesting. Very very well done.

#2 - A bit busy for me. The first thing my eyes go to is Cloud's right arm, then to Cloud's hair, then to the motion around him. It took me a long while to finally notice Aeris off in the corner, and it took about three or so minutes to notice the 'CloudxAerith' in the corner. The effects were very well done, though.

#3 - The colors are a bit bland for me, but I like the softness around Aeris and Cloud, as well as how much their eyes stand out. Font choice was good, but I think the text just needs to be more profound to make this siggy choice.

#4 - A very aquatic feel, and I have a feeling I know whose this is. :P Regardless, the simplicity of the signature is very remarkable, and the lighting effects makes it seem really... cute. Yeah, I said cute. A close 2nd place for me.
 
Back
Top