SotW 232 Voting Thread.
- Thread starter Six
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2011
- Messages
- 3,050
- Location
- In another Palace stealing Hearts.
- Gil
- 8
- FFXIV
- Kuro Narukami
- FFXIV Server
- Lamia
#1 for me I love the NoelxSerah pairing now xD, and I love the artwork used and how its blended in so well, loved everything about this one 
!
#4 would have gotten my vote if #1 wasn't my favorite XD #4 is so cool yet beautiful
Wish I could vote for them both D:
!#4 would have gotten my vote if #1 wasn't my favorite XD #4 is so cool yet beautiful
Wish I could vote for them both D:
2 for me.
I don't know what it is here that just appeals to me. It's different from most signatures that follow the rule of thirds and are faithful to realistic lighting. I think it could've been better blended, but the creator took many risks visually (which to me, really works), and I think that deserves credit.
I don't know what it is here that just appeals to me. It's different from most signatures that follow the rule of thirds and are faithful to realistic lighting. I think it could've been better blended, but the creator took many risks visually (which to me, really works), and I think that deserves credit.
Voted for #2. 
I like the text and the attempt at a space / time theme. Its not easy to do, I give you props for trying. This piece may not have came off as well as you would have liked, but if you keep trying maybe you'll nail it eventually & it'll be amazing.
I like the text and the attempt at a space / time theme. Its not easy to do, I give you props for trying. This piece may not have came off as well as you would have liked, but if you keep trying maybe you'll nail it eventually & it'll be amazing.
Honestly, I like the simplicity of #1 the best. The lighting is perfect to capture the mood, the characters stick out just right, all around good job.
#2....it's good, really, but there's a lot going on in it and I don't know where exactly I should focus.
#3 I do like what you were trying to do with the lighting, but the text kinda bugs me. it looks like it's just stuck in the middle, like a last minute addition.
#4 Beautiful blending of your render, and the background is beautiful as well. It was a tough debate between this one and 1, but just the sweetness and simplicity of 1 ruled out in the end.
#2....it's good, really, but there's a lot going on in it and I don't know where exactly I should focus.
#3 I do like what you were trying to do with the lighting, but the text kinda bugs me. it looks like it's just stuck in the middle, like a last minute addition.
#4 Beautiful blending of your render, and the background is beautiful as well. It was a tough debate between this one and 1, but just the sweetness and simplicity of 1 ruled out in the end.
Congratulations to Lirael for winning this Sotw!
1. Stevie
2. Sabriel
3. Afterglow
4. Lirael (winner!)
Shu, Mitsuki, may I have this closed & archived?
And these guidelines archived as well: Linky.
1. Stevie
2. Sabriel
3. Afterglow
4. Lirael (winner!)
Shu, Mitsuki, may I have this closed & archived?
And these guidelines archived as well: Linky.