SOTW 23 Voting Thread

[Daenerys]

This week the theme was Winter, and i recieved these two entries -

1)

2)

 

[Scrutator]

Number 1 for this week.

 

[Davey Gaga]

It has to be number two.

 

[Mitsuki]

Number 2. I love the graphic. Number 1 is bright though, which I also like. But 2 catches my attention more.

 

[AlchemistFox]

nr 1 is cute, but nr 2 rules.
the the fact that it say "Final Fantasy Forums" on the building, makes it all much better

 

[Shahab]

This week the theme was Winter, and i recieved these two entries -

1)

2)

Is not the theme WINTER ?
The first sig has just the name of winter on it. I see leaves there instead of snow... Nothing about winter.
Looks nice, but nothing to do with the theme.

 

[Bambi]

Number 2 is defo more wintery & im liking the snow.....but I think I prefer number one cause it's cute

 

[Scrutator]

Is not the theme WINTER ?
The first sig has just the name of winter on it. I see leaves there instead of snow... Nothing about winter.
Looks nice, but nothing to do with the theme.

The character is wearing winter clothing and the colours/effects in the back look like frost. It's fine for a Winter theme and a far better made sig than Number 2 which looks nice but at the heart of it is a very plain design.

 

[Gabe]

NUMBER TWOOO! It pwns because it is animated with snow and the Merry Christmas thing on the side looks pwnage, and the house with Final Fantasy Fourms on it also plain pwnage!

 

[Matrix]

definitely no #1 .. awesome ^.* it has more depth than the other one also great colors working with the theme and the character in the same time ..yeap like what scrutator siad you can tell its about snow from her clothes or colors perhaps the only mistake was in the leaves if he/she put little white shiny spots it would be better otherwaise great great job =D

 

[L]

I liked number one better. Has a nice winter feel an' shit.

Well done.