This sig any good?

[Sala Salabim]

Would you say this sig is any good I just made?

I know I could of put the reddish star thing somewhere else when I think about it now and I sharpened tidus's face a bit too much. Oh and I was tired so couldnt be bothered with a snazzy Font. I havnt made any for awhile now and thought I may aswell see if I get any better.

 

[Big Casino]

I really like your background, the colours are different but i actually quite like it. Although i dont think the red c4d at the bottom fits. My main problem is that there is an out line round the render, very noticible around his face. Is quite off putting. If you got rid of that it would look really good.
Well done.

 

[Sala Salabim]

Okay thanks. Im going to try do one with an actual person tommorow.

 

[Rey]

You know what this is actually a good siggy. Well not the best but it is better than what I would do lol. Im horrible at photoshop. I never was good at gfx tbqh. Great colors though.

 

[Aurelie]

if you looked at just Yuna and excluded Tidus, thus having the render only show up on Yuna's side, it would look good, but as a whole with them both in the sig, it does not fit.

let me illustrate: hypothetically you cut off everything (including Tidus) to the right of Yuna's boob and make just Yuna in her own image sig thing. if your render was just solely put there near her boob, it becomes the light source and fits. a light source doesn't go and frolic on Tidus' arm, though.

I'm also a fan of smaller signatures, so I think your sig is too big. your text also does not seem to fit with the whole signature, but then again I myself don't like text anymore because I do not know how to place it.

all in all this is a good attempt and I can see your color sense and idea. thumbs up!

 

[Kei]

This is actually good, your background looks good but I'm not sure about the amount of effects you included there, maybe if you cut out some of them it would look better, I think you did good, if you're new in this and haven't made one for a while.

 

[Gingerbread Lesbian]

I like it, you seem to have the the basics plus a bit more which is brilliant. The background is effective and blends well with the Tidus/Yuna render. The effects are good as well. You could probably do without the text though, especially on a larger piece. Keep up the good work.