Corporations: Morality or No?

Shu

Spiral out, Keep going..
Veteran
Joined
Nov 21, 2006
Messages
2,926
Age
40
Location
Nashville, TN
Gil
25
Bomb
Black Mage
Terra
Cloud Strife
FFXIV
Shu
FFXIV Server
Lamia
This is worldly, so before I start this, don't make this just about the UK's/US's/AUS's corporations - try to think general. Later in this thread I'm going to apply this debate solely around Microsoft's company due to how much I've seen, and since they are a good example (not solely based around conspiracy, but because some folks are blind).

The main question is.. can corporations be subjected to Morality? Can you call one evil, or good?

The main reason I ask this is because in a capitalistic society the whole point is to make money individually and privately. Meaning the government usually has no way to intervene, so you are able to seek individual profit. The only problem is when one (entity or person) owns a majority of a product line, they get some flack and are sometimes subjected to words like Monopoly. (Microsoft). The thing is though, if you own the majority of the product line, you can actually control the market (i.e. Supply and Demand). This is where morality comes into play.

If say, one company sees the competition starting to rise, when they have been the big dogs for a quarter century (AT&T), the company either buys the competition out, or tries to get into litigation against them.

Without competition though, the market is dominated by these corporations. If someone comes out with a new cable for instance with higher bandwidth transmissions at a reasonable price (overhead [materials to make it]), the corporations will try to by this out, in order to up the price without people being aware of how much the overhead cost in the first place.

People will pay it, because they are ignorant and unaware of how cheap the materials were, so in my opinion these corporations can be pretty freakin evil, but then again, is it really? In a capitalistic society anything goes usually, unless of course copyright infringement occurs or something goofy occurs with the accounting/stock options. Though this does not occur as much due to only ONE company on top of all others.

When folks have to worry about patents, copy rights, and other stuff of this nature, it leaves little room for competition in the market place. Now because of it people are making more money by buying out a product and selling it over amazon. As in up-selling a certain item. i.e. - you buy a product on amazon for $15.00 bucks, then turn around and change the description and put a better image out there for the product and sell it on amazon for $30.00. It's called manipulating the market place.

It hurts companies when you do this by the way. When you buy used games for instance, the game companies don't gain a cent. Only buying new games will they gain anything. At least Microsoft cut a deal with gaming companies that whatever DLC they sell, the gaming companies can make a profit.

That's all I got for now, so what is your opinion in a capitalistic society can you really call a corporation evil? Or are they just trying doing exactly as they are supposed to, since there are no laws against it.
 
When I see companies in general, all I personally see is immorality.

1) Enron-
"More than 5,000 jobs and $1 billion in employee retirement funds were wiped out when Enron plunged into bankruptcy in December 2001, after widespread accounting fraud was revealed."
Source- http://articles.latimes.com/2009/jan/03/business/fi-kopper3
If this isn't immorality, I don't know what is. Can you imagine working years and years sticking money into a retirement fund and having your company steal it all away from you when you are on the verge of retirement? Basically these people might very well end up working for the rest of their lives. Theres no way those people are going to get their money back, and those people are going to end up living out the rest of their lives paying for the corruption of their former employer...and the sad fact is, there is little justice for them in this situation, as it seems like if you have any sort of money nowadays you can get away with pretty much anything in our judicial system because I don't think those who were responsible from Enron were punished 1/3 of what they actually deserved.

2) Microsoft- and this is stating the obvious, but I have never used a pc without some form of their operating system on it. I know there are others out there, like Ubuntu (Linux) and Mac, but you hardly ever see them being used Microsoft has a monopoly and they like keeping it that way...I believe they are purposely snuffing out the competiton to keep their monopoly and I don't believe that is right....However that is the norm nowadays in society.

3) Intel- Same with Microsoft, they prefer having a monopoly. Every pc I've ever bought has some sort of Intel processor in it.
Also: "Capping a decade-long push by the federal government to check the power of this country's biggest tech companies, the Federal Trade Commission is banning Intel from a slew of practices deemed unfair and deceptive as part of an antitrust settlement over charges that the firm exploited its dominance in the chip market to elbow out competitors." Source- http://www.washingtonpost.com/wpdyn/content/article/2010/08/04/AR2010080402592.html


Companies are getting so greedy that they don't care who they trample along the way to get the almighty dollar. As I see it, any time there is a lot of money involved, there is always corruption involved, even if it is behind closed doors... and whether we see it in the news or not.
 
Companies are getting so greedy that they don't care who they trample along the way to get the almighty dollar. As I see it, any time there is a lot of money involved, there is always corruption involved, even if it is behind closed doors... and whether we see it in the news or not.

this. also i prefer amd :wacky:

greed is the way of the land. fair enough we all have to survive, but i dont think anyone needs millions of pounds/dollars a year to live even a fairly comfortable life. morality doesnt apply, if its not illegal theres not very much anyone can do about it. morality is just an afterthought.

i think the problem with these massive companies is often that theyre faceless...until something goes wrong (a la bp) then you have hundreds of people shrugging and saying "i didnt do it" then it comes back to the big man who for the most party just sits on a yacht with a glass of wine for most of the year.

:mokken:
 
Corporations are a byproduct of capitalism. They're doing exactly what they were designed to do in a capitalistic society. If you call corporations evil, it's likely that you have a problem with capitalism rather than the corporations themselves.

I think it's a disconnect to try to analyze an entity (corporation) in a system (capitalism) that promotes the kind of choices that are "greedy" by focusing solely on the corporation. It sounds more like you have a problem with capitalism rather than corporations imo.
 
Back
Top