SOTW 19 Voting Thread

[Angel Valentine]

It was an open theme this week ^o^ (a.k.a. whatever you wanted to do)

1.)

2.)

3.)

4.)

 

[Davey Gaga]

I went for #3 this week. #1 looks amazing but I can't make out or determine what any part of it is and, as such, it gets my second vote, if we had such a chance xD
#3 looks very ... I don't know, it just looks really good xD

 

[Bambi]

I like number 3, it's pretty

 

[Scarlet]

My vote goes to signature 1. The colors, the small computer scans, futuristic theme works great with the picture of Samus. (Well Metroid is futuristic...) >_>

 

[Mugen]

Voted #1, it's a complete sig, excellent use of stock, the background and text are also great, I am just wondering if brushes were used... but it makes no difference, it's the best out of the 4 IMO, the others are nice tries, but are simple. #3 Looks like a resized pic to me..

 

[AlchemistFox]

numero uno (AKA. number 1)

du to the fat taht samus is more or less futuristic.
it seemd perfectly that the whole sig, had a computer feel

 

[Davey Gaga]

If two people have voted for #3, then why does it only have one vote? No one has voted for #2 but it still has a vote, and I could've sworn that #4 had a vote last night

 

[Daenerys]

This thing needs to be a public poll in future. Srsly. Anyway i vote for number 4, why? Just cause

 

[Demaian]

I like the first because to me, it looks like it has the cleanest act put together. The others just seem to be falling short. If you don't want to read criticism, then stop reading my post now.

Beatrix one looks stretched and its slapped onto a not very appealing background with colors I'm too familiar with. I'm not asking for advant grade, but it could use something new. The Keyblade one just looks like a crop to me. If you rendered it, well then the tag was just a crop of that wasn't it? Put a little more effort into the actual tag is what I'm saying. The last one feels uninspired. Pulling some grunge move offs and giant text, feels like a joke with what the actual text is saying, which I'm sure it is.

 

[Shahab]

No #1 g I like how the invironment effects are match with

thee stock and blended well without loosing it's sharpness.
Also the text and Zeometric effects related to the image and

made it so good.


#2 I am sure its Aerith Gainsborough's entry.
The text is not good for me. I can't see any foreground in

the image and its just two sets of layers, BG and Stock over

it.
Nice colors but did not bland well... I prefer Aerith

Gainsborough's avatar more then this one.


No#3 well, except lights placement, I don't see anything

else special with it. It would have my vote if it had more

invironment and atmosphere effects or atleast the text was

good enough ( The whiteglow around the text does not match

the image itself atall )

No #4 ... Hmmm, I am not sure but maybe its Eidlon...
Nice work, I really like this one too specially how the eye

glows effected eyelashes. Very nice blending and I really

love this kind of Realistic color-invironment and it would

have my vote if just the text was not so mono and had some

BG effects into it ( for example a layer of text with

softlight blending and a 40% layer OVERLY blending over it.
Or maybe some of the fog effects left to the face were

around the text too... I appreciate this one. I love it.


Its really hard to choose between 1 and 4.... Both are great

but in different styles.



I say its not fair to choose between these two.
I vote for #1
But wish I was able to vote for both.


I won't say why I voted No-1
Just enough to say I have a reason for it.


I think its enough that moderators see who has voted for

whom.
Its better to remain as a secret for public that who voted whom. Just if mods know it is enough.

 

[Ironman]

i love 3 due to it's simplicity and the fact that i absolutely LOVE the key blade

 

[Misty]

1. Bloody fantastic - it's so beautiful and well done.

^So I voteded it.

2. Too stretched.

3. A simple pic of a keyblade with words does not do it for me..

4. It's alright, like the shiny eyes.