Cid by far! Barret was just a Mr.T clone with a gun on his arm. Cool but not a singe on Cid!
Cid was always swearing, always being bad ass, has an airship and plane, Dragoon-type character, convenirantly carrys Dynamite in his pocket, and ALWAYS having a fag. yep even at the end of the world with his impending death before him he kicks back and lights up a cancer stick! (I'm a none smoker and don't think its good too but admittedly he gives it style

)