I want to know the answers to your questions too!
Quote:
Originally Posted by smudge
But even LOTR doesn’t quench my thirst for fantasy like playing FF7 did.
|
That's quite obvious. LOTR is "high fantasy", which is actually very, very different from "soft fantasy". High fantasy generally entails pre-industrial, sparsely-populated worlds of orcs, goblins, elves, dwarves, dragons etc and the battles and machinations of various pseudo-political entities and mages. Soft fantasy, though, can be anything that contains something magical, like time-travelling portals or wish-granting fairies. The first five Final Fantasies are mainly high fantasy but even FFI spoke of an ancient technological civilisation and even took you to its flying fortress.
Similarly, "hard sci-fi" is very different from "soft sci-fi". The former is the stuff of Asimov, with robots and space-faring vehicles and galactic colonisation. The latter tends to be set in technological societies but de-emphasises this fact, and probably doesn't entail interplanetary stuff. I think FF12 falls into this category, but I'm not sure.
FF7 (and 8) is therefore obviously soft sci-fi, mixed with some soft fantasy. FF10 is predominantly soft fantasy, but as in all the FF games, elements of both technology and magic are always present.
I know it doesn't answer your questions, but I too am very interested in this merger of soft fantasy and soft sci-fi that the FF series achieves; I'm not at all interested in the "hard" stuff which tends to give the "sci-fi/fantasy" genre a niche appearance that it doesn't deserve.
The "Otherland" series by Tad Williams is sci-fi for sure, but it's similar to FF in many ways: there's a group of people who assemble with a common goal and they go on a very long journey to uncover the truth and defeat their common enemy. Most of the last three books take place in a variety of fantastical Virtual Reality environments, which adds a fantasy element.